What is the connection between the thyroid and the immune system?
The thyroid and the immune system are closely intertwined: in Hashimoto's disease the immune system attacks the thyroid itself, and selenium can measurably reduce that immune activity.
In Hashimoto's disease, the most common cause of an underactive thyroid in Western countries, the body's own immune system attacks the thyroid. Both certain white blood cells and antibodies, particularly so-called anti-thyroid antibodies, target thyroid tissue. This leads to gradual scarring and eventually a thyroid that produces too few hormones.
Why this happens is partly down to genetics: more than 60 risk genes have been found, including genes that control the brakes on the immune system. But genes alone do not explain it. Environmental factors and small chemical changes on DNA can also throw the immune system out of balance. It is an interplay of causes, not a single one.
People who have one autoimmune condition more often have a second one too. Thyroid autoimmunity frequently goes hand in hand with autoimmune conditions affecting other glands, such as type 1 diabetes or Addison's disease. Exactly how these are connected has not yet been fully clarified, but the association is well documented.
COVID-19 can harm the thyroid both directly and indirectly. The virus can infect thyroid cells, but it can also trigger a strong immune overreaction that disrupts thyroid function. In some people with lasting symptoms after COVID, persistent thyroid problems have been described, partly because ongoing low-level immune activity can worsen an existing Hashimoto's process.
For people with Hashimoto's, selenium is the best-supported dietary supplement. Many studies show that taking selenium daily noticeably reduces anti-thyroid antibodies, with side effects no worse than those of a sugar pill. Thyroid hormone levels themselves did not change measurably as a result, so selenium is not a replacement for thyroid hormone tablets, but it can dampen immune activity. A gluten-free diet is sometimes recommended for Hashimoto's, but three small studies produced contradictory results: some antibody levels fell, other antibody levels actually rose, and there was no effect on hormone levels. There is currently no scientific basis for recommending it.
This answer draws on several combined analyses of many studies, including two on selenium supplementation (together covering 35 studies and more than 2,300 participants) and one smaller combined analysis on the gluten-free diet (three studies, 110 participants). The researchers behind the gluten-free analysis rated their own findings as seriously to extremely uncertain. The link between COVID-19 and thyroid problems is based on one combined overview of many studies; a causal relationship is plausible but has not yet been definitively established. The mechanism of Hashimoto's disease (an immune system attack on the thyroid) is well documented and widely accepted as causal.
What is the relationship between your thyroid and depressive symptoms?
There is a clear association between thyroid problems and depressive symptoms, although the precise direction of influence has not yet been fully established. If you have persistent low mood and doubts about your thyroid function, discuss with your doctor whether testing is worthwhile.
What does your thyroid do to your metabolism and energy?
Your thyroid controls how fast your body burns energy through the hormones it produces: too little hormone slows everything down, too much sends everything into overdrive. A blood test can show straightaway how your thyroid is performing.
What does too much or too little iodine do to your thyroid?
Both too little and too much iodine can disrupt the thyroid; make sure you get enough each day, but avoid large supplements without a medical reason, especially if you have an existing thyroid condition.
Why do you develop thyroid problems after giving birth?
After delivery, the brake on the immune system lifts abruptly, which can trigger inflammation in women with an underlying predisposition to thyroid autoimmunity. Symptoms such as extreme fatigue, palpitations or weight fluctuations in the first year after delivery are a reason to have your thyroid checked.
Can your thyroid be damaged by eating too few calories?
Eating too few calories does not cause lasting damage to the thyroid itself. What does happen: your body temporarily lowers the production of the active thyroid hormone as an energy-saving response.
Can your thyroid be normal on a test but still cause symptoms?
Yes, a normal test result does not rule out thyroid-related symptoms. If you continue to have symptoms after a normal result, discuss with your doctor whether there are measurement errors or whether a more thorough assessment is warranted.