Can you have too much body fat while being at a healthy weight?
Yes, a normal weight does not automatically mean you have little body fat. Too much fat, and especially too much belly fat, raises your risk of diabetes, heart and metabolic problems, and certain cancers, even when the scales show nothing worrying.
Yes, you can. People with a normal BMI but too high a body-fat percentage, sometimes called 'normal weight obesity', have considerably higher chances of heart and metabolic problems than people with both a normal weight and a normal body-fat percentage. Across nearly 178,000 participants, researchers saw the strongest difference for metabolic syndrome (1.9 times as high) and high triglycerides (blood fats). Raised blood sugar, low good cholesterol, type 2 diabetes and high blood pressure were also more common. The link is clear, but whether the fat itself is the cause or whether other factors play a role has not been fully established.
Belly fat is the most deceptive part of this. A measure that combines belly fat with blood-fat values shows that people with a lot of belly fat but a normal outward appearance develop type 2 diabetes twice as often as people with little belly fat. Researchers explicitly call this the 'thin on the outside, fat on the inside' phenotype.
The risk of certain cancers is also relevant. People with a normal weight but metabolic problems due to excess fat had a raised risk of specific cancer types in several studies. The risk of uterine, liver and kidney cancer was strongly raised in people with both excess weight and metabolic problems. But even people with a normal weight and metabolic problems already had a higher risk of some cancers compared with people without metabolic problems. Interestingly, a separate large British study found that a normal weight was in itself protective against cancer risk, regardless of how active a person was. That study measured only BMI, however, not body-fat percentage, which is an important distinction.
What can you do about it? Aerobic exercise, such as running or cycling, reduces visceral fat even in people with a normal weight. Longer training periods of more than five months produced the largest effects, although the evidence for this is still limited. On the diet side, a high-protein diet lowers body-fat percentage more than simply eating less. Restricting calories alone led to hardly any reduction in fat and also caused a loss of muscle mass. The evidence base for this dietary approach is small and the findings are preliminary.
This answer draws on several large summaries of existing research, including an analysis of nearly 178,000 participants looking at cardiometabolic risks. For cancer risk, the researchers rated some of the analyses as high certainty (for example for thyroid and liver cancer) and some as moderate or low certainty (such as for pancreatic cancer). The findings on exercise and diet come from smaller studies with methodological limitations; the researchers themselves point to wide variation between studies and call for better-designed research. The evidence on the risks is therefore stronger than the evidence on the solutions.
I am overweight. What will losing weight do for me?
Losing weight produces measurable health gains, particularly for your waist size, blood sugar, and blood fat levels. How you go about it matters less than whether you can keep it up.
How dangerous is a fatty liver (hepatic steatosis)?
For most people a fatty liver is stable for the time being, but it substantially raises the risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes and liver disease; losing weight is so far the only proven way to limit the damage.
Does the timing of meals throughout the day affect your weight?
When you eat matters: meals earlier in the day appear more favourable for your metabolism than eating late, although the effect varies from person to person and the strongest evidence is still based on short-term studies.
Does 150 minutes of exercise per week help reduce liver fat?
Exercise clearly reduces liver fat, and you do not necessarily need to reach 150 minutes per week to benefit. Both aerobic training and strength training help; start with what is achievable and build from there.
Does eating more fibre help against high blood sugar?
Water-soluble fibre from legumes, vegetables and fruit probably helps lower high blood sugar, but the overall composition of the meal also plays a role. For type 2 diabetes and gestational diabetes, consulting a doctor is always necessary.
Does eating low-carb make a difference for belly fat?
Eating low-carb measurably reduces belly fat, especially if you are already overweight or have metabolic problems. Combining it with time-restricted eating works even better.