Does a vegetarian diet weaken your bones?
A vegetarian diet does not automatically weaken your bones, but as a vegan you need to pay extra attention to calcium and vitamin B12. Make sure you get enough of both, and the increased fracture risk can largely be prevented.
Vegans have, on average, lower bone density than people who eat everything, but whether that also leads to more fractures depends strongly on calcium intake. Many studies combined conclude that vegans who get enough calcium do not face a higher fracture risk. People who consistently take in too little calcium, however, do have a higher risk of osteoporotic fractures. Vitamin B12 deficiency, for which vegans need supplementation regardless, can further undermine bone health.
The picture varies across studies. Research among postmenopausal women in Taiwan found that long-term vegans had almost 2.5 times the rate of low bone density in the lower back, and almost 4 times the rate of fragile bones in the hip. Older Chinese vegetarian women had clearly lower hip bone density than meat-eaters. On the other hand, a large Taiwanese study of 1,865 people found no difference at all in bone density or bone loss between vegetarians and non-vegetarians. And Vietnamese postmenopausal women who had lived as vegans their whole lives barely differed from meat-eaters in bone density, despite taking in considerably less calcium (a mineral that keeps your bones strong) and protein.
One explanation for the contradictory results: vegetarians weigh less on average, and lower body weight on its own already puts less pressure on the bones, which causes bone density to come out lower. When you correct for this, the difference in the hip disappears completely. For the lower back, a small but measurable difference remained.
Lacto-ovo-vegetarians (who do eat dairy and eggs) fare more favourably. In a long-term study of women aged 80, they had lost 18% of bone mass, compared with 35% in meat-eaters. This difference is linked to a more favourable calcium-to-phosphorus ratio and less acid-forming food in the vegetarian diet.
In practical terms: for lacto-ovo-vegetarians, the available research does not point to worsening bones. For vegans, the picture is more nuanced. Adequate calcium (from fortified foods or a supplement) and vitamin B12 are essential. Also pay attention to factors such as oxalic acid and phytic acid in plant-based foods, which can reduce calcium absorption.
All sources are studies that track people over time or reviews that were not carried out to a strict method, often in specific groups (postmenopausal Asian women, Buddhist nuns). No trials where people were randomly assigned to a diet are available. It is therefore not possible to say that a vegetarian diet directly causes changes in bone health.
Is eating plant-based bad for your bones?
Eating strictly vegan is associated with lower bone density, but if you adequately supplement calcium and vitamin D, the elevated fracture risk largely disappears. As a vegan, also pay attention to vitamin B12, and discuss any supplement use with your GP or dietitian.
Does drinking a lot of alcohol weaken your bones?
Chronic heavy drinking demonstrably weakens your bones and substantially raises the risk of a hip fracture; for your bones there is no safe level above two drinks per day.
Can too much vitamin A weaken your bones?
Vitamin A from everyday food has no negative effect on your bones. Long-term high doses of retinol supplements are associated with bone loss.
Does taking cortisone long-term weaken your bones?
Long-term cortisone use demonstrably weakens your bones; if you use it long-term, it is wise to discuss with your doctor whether you are a candidate for bisphosphonates as a protective measure.
Can having too little body fat damage your bones?
Too little fat can damage your bones, but muscle mass and the location of fat matter at least as much. If you have concerns about bone health in combination with low body fat, discuss this with your general practitioner or sports medicine physician.
Do you really need calcium supplements for strong bones?
Whether you need calcium supplements depends strongly on your age and situation: for healthy women before the menopause there is no evidence of benefit, while women over 50 may benefit from calcium plus vitamin D, provided you weigh the increased risk of kidney stones and the uncertain cardiac risk with your doctor.