Can aspartame contribute to hardening of the arteries?
Large population studies see an association between aspartame and cardiovascular disease, but whether aspartame causes that association has not been demonstrated.
Large studies involving more than 400,000 people found that regular use of artificial sweeteners, including aspartame, is associated with more cardiovascular disease, higher blood pressure, metabolic syndrome, and type 2 diabetes. For strokes, and especially strokes caused by a blood clot, most of twelve studies examined showed the same association. Women and people of African descent appeared to face a greater risk.
This association is not the same as proof of cause and effect, however. One plausible explanation is that people who are already in poor health more often choose sweeteners: they drink diet soft drinks to save calories, while their lifestyle already raises their cardiovascular risk. In studies where the researchers themselves determined who used sweeteners and who did not, the effects on body weight and cardiometabolic measures did not emerge consistently.
At a molecular level there are indications, mainly from animal studies and experiments with cells, that sweeteners such as aspartame may promote inflammation in the walls of blood vessels, disrupt how blood vessels function, and alter the gut bacteria in a way that interferes with sugar metabolism. Those are plausible routes toward hardening of the arteries, but this has not yet been firmly proven in people. How aspartame specifically contributes to plaque build-up in arteries therefore remains an open question.
In practical terms: the evidence is not strong enough to identify aspartame as a proven cause of hardening of the arteries, but the association with cardiovascular problems seen in large population studies is real enough not to ignore. Anyone who already has an elevated cardiovascular risk is best advised to discuss with a doctor whether cutting back on artificially sweetened drinks makes sense.
This answer draws on two comprehensive reviews (one with data from more than 400,000 people) and a recent study into possible underlying mechanisms. The evidence from the large population studies is based solely on association: people were followed over time but were not assigned to any group. That makes it impossible to separate cause from effect. The researchers themselves stress that distortions caused by pre-existing illness and lifestyle may skew the picture. The mechanistic study comes largely from animal studies and experiments with cells, and has not yet been confirmed in people. The evidence is therefore limited and inconsistent: too serious to dismiss, but too weak for firm conclusions.