Can you safely eat cheese if you are watching your heart health?
Eating cheese in moderation does not appear to carry extra heart risk for most people, and compared with butter it actually performs better when it comes to cholesterol.
Cheese contains saturated fat and sodium, two things that, looked at in isolation, are not good for the heart. Yet studies have repeatedly shown that people who eat more cheese do not develop more heart and cardiovascular disease; if anything, they develop less than people who eat little cheese. This is an association; whether cheese itself is the cause has not been proven.
One explanation researchers point to is the so-called cheese matrix: cheese is not simply a sum of fat and salt, but a coherent food containing proteins, bacteria and minerals that together work differently than the individual components do on their own. Compared with an equivalent amount of butter fat, cheese lowers LDL cholesterol (the 'bad' cholesterol) by an average of 0.19 mmol/L and total cholesterol by 0.24 mmol/L. That is a modest but measurable benefit.
For blood pressure the picture is similar: people who eat more dairy have a slightly lower risk of high blood pressure. The effect is modest, and cheese and milk have not always been studied separately.
The type of dairy and the broader context make a difference. In countries where full-fat milk is the main dairy consumed, eating more dairy was actually linked to a higher risk of heart attack. In countries where cheese and low-fat milk are the norm, the picture was more favourable. This means that 'dairy is good for your heart' is too simple a statement; what you eat also matters.
For most people who eat cheese in moderation, the available evidence does not point in a worrying direction. If you already have heart or cardiovascular disease, or if you take medication for your cholesterol, discuss with your doctor how much and what type of dairy is appropriate for you.
This answer draws on several large summaries of existing research, including four analyses combining many studies and two comprehensive evidence reviews, plus one study that directly compared cheese and butter. The researchers themselves note that the quality of the evidence is low to moderate, with considerable variation between studies. This means the associations found may be real, but their precise size and cause remain uncertain. None of the large studies can prove cause and effect for long-term heart outcomes; only the cholesterol comparison with butter has stronger causal evidence.