Do vitamin E or selenium supplements help prevent dementia in older adults?
Several large studies examined vitamin E and selenium as protection against dementia, including in people who are already cognitively vulnerable. Neither supplement showed any effect on the likelihood of developing dementia.
Taking high doses of vitamin E does not help prevent or slow dementia. In people with mild cognitive impairment, who are already vulnerable, taking 2000 IU of vitamin E per day for three years produced no measurable effect: not on the likelihood of developing Alzheimer's disease, not on memory, daily functioning, or survival. In people who already have Alzheimer's, the picture is the same: antioxidant supplements such as vitamin E show no benefit for thinking ability or daily functioning.
Selenium fares no better. In a large study of more than 3,700 participants, taking selenium for approximately five years made no difference in the number of new dementia cases. The researchers themselves note that the certainty of this evidence is low, but the direction is consistent: no effect.
There is one exception that muddies the picture. Studies in which people were followed for years without being given anything show that people who naturally consume more vitamin E and C through food or supplements develop Alzheimer's disease less often. But that evidence does not show cause and effect: it could just as easily be because people who eat healthily also live healthily in other ways.
A concrete safety concern: in a large study, men who took vitamin E developed prostate cancer much more often than men who did not. This is a reason to look especially critically at vitamin E as a preventive supplement for men. For the target areas of heart and blood vessel health, skin, and fertility, the available data likewise do not support vitamin E.
The researchers behind these assessments repeatedly note that the certainty of the evidence is low to moderate, including for the negative outcomes. But that low certainty does not mean vitamin E or selenium might still work: the available studies consistently point to no effect, and the only signal pointing the other way, namely less dementia at higher intake, does not come from a controlled study and does not prove any causal relationship.
This answer draws on several combined summaries of studies in people, including research in people with mild memory problems, in cognitively healthy older adults, and in people with Alzheimer's disease. The researchers themselves rate the evidence for vitamin E and selenium on thinking ability and dementia as low certainty, including for the negative outcomes. One specific outcome, the effect on thinking ability after an average of eight years, was rated as low certainty; the finding on selenium and new dementia cases comes from a single study and likewise carries a rating of "low certainty." The finding that higher vitamin E intake through food is linked to a lower Alzheimer's risk comes from studies in which people were not assigned anything at random, so cause and effect cannot be inferred from them. The safety signal for prostate cancer with vitamin E use in men is of moderate quality and relevant enough to mention.