longevitywatch

Does an ECG (heart tracing) make sense if you have no symptoms?

Moderate evidence

An ECG can detect silent heart problems such as atrial fibrillation in people without symptoms. It is most worthwhile if you already have an elevated risk, and in that case it is worth discussing with your GP.

An ECG can reveal atrial fibrillation (an irregular heart rhythm) earlier in people who have no symptoms at all. The difference is especially large for people over 65 with other risk factors: a smartwatch with an ECG function picked up nearly five times as many new cases of atrial fibrillation as standard care. Several of those episodes were completely symptom-free, so without an ECG those people would never have known their heart was beating out of rhythm. A wearable ECG patch worn at home for two weeks produces similar results.

The problem is that finding atrial fibrillation early does not automatically lead to fewer strokes. The number of diagnoses did rise with screening, but the number of strokes was barely different between the screened and unscreened group after two and a half years. Wearables can detect an irregular rhythm well, but whether that also protects you against a stroke or early death has not yet been shown. On top of that, blood thinners prescribed after such a diagnosis lower the chance of a stroke but also raise the risk of serious bleeding.

A standard ECG also reveals things beyond the heart's rhythm. Signs of a thickened left heart muscle on an ECG are linked to a 50 to 90 percent higher chance of a serious heart event or death. An abnormal electrical axis in the heart is even associated with a 40 to 70 percent higher risk of death. These are silent findings: people do not feel them, but they are visible on a standard ECG. As a warning signal, an ECG therefore has value even without any symptoms.

Not everyone benefits equally from screening. When everyone is simply invited regardless of risk, the yield is low: studies showed that screening without prior risk selection produced no clear advantage. When a smart risk assessment was combined with a longer period of heart monitoring, that same research found more than five times as many new cases as usual care. Only 32 people needed to be invited to reach one additional diagnosis. An ECG as a detection tool works best, then, in people who already have an elevated risk.

The evidence
7 studies · 3 meta-analyses · 3 randomised trials · ≈ 270,000 participants

This answer draws on several studies in people over 65, two large analyses that followed tens of thousands of people over longer periods, and a review of wearable devices. The findings on detecting atrial fibrillation are reasonably consistent and come from well-designed research. Whether early detection actually prevents strokes remains unanswered: no study in people has demonstrated that effect to date. The risk findings for a thickened heart muscle and an abnormal electrical axis come from large analyses of 58,400 and 164,000 people respectively, which makes those findings more solid, although they reflect associations rather than proven cause and effect.

Last checked: November 2026 · how this was judged
Related answers

Is a heart-rhythm reading from your smartwatch (ECG) worth using?

A smartwatch ECG is a reliable first step for flagging atrial fibrillation. A doctor's ECG is still needed to confirm any alert before you act on it.

Yes · Moderate evidence

Should I take statins if I have (not yet) had a heart problem?

Whether statins are worthwhile depends on your personal risk. At a calculated 10-year risk of 10% or higher and at least one risk factor, such as high blood pressure, diabetes or smoking, major guidelines recommend statins for people aged 40 to 75.

Strong evidence

Is a calcium score of my heart worth doing?

For people between 40 and 75 years old in a grey zone regarding statins, a calcium score is a well-supported tool for making a well-considered decision about medication together with your doctor.

Yes · Strong evidence

Should you worry about mildly elevated cholesterol?

A mildly elevated cholesterol is not automatically harmless: the overall picture, including triglycerides and lipoprotein(a), determines your risk. Have those values measured and discuss them with your doctor if cardiovascular disease runs in your family.

Moderate evidence

Are calcium supplements bad for your heart?

Calcium supplements may be associated with an increased heart risk, but not all studies confirm this. It is best to get calcium from your diet, and discuss with your doctor whether a supplement is truly necessary for you.

Moderate evidence

Are erectile problems an early sign of heart disease?

Erectile problems caused by poor blood flow precede a heart attack or stroke by an average of 2 to 5 years. If you have this type of complaint, also have your cardiovascular risk checked by your doctor.

Related research
20 Nov
Fat cells secrete a molecule that ages blood vessels in mice
19 Nov
Cholesterol buildup in lung immune cells triggers fibrosis in mice
19 Nov
Signaling molecule from aging heart valve cells linked to spread of calcification
Don't see your question?
Ask it and we'll look it up for you.
Ask a question →
Newsletter

Stay in the loop

Every Thursday, the most important longevity research in your inbox, focused on what you follow.