Does intermittent fasting combined with high-protein meals help with weight loss?
Research shows that intermittent fasting works for weight loss, performing about as well as simply eating less. Combine it with exercise and enough protein to also protect your muscles.
Alternate-day fasting, where you fast every other day, produced on average about 1.3 kg more weight loss in the short term than simply eating fewer calories. But that advantage disappeared in studies lasting longer than 24 weeks. Over the longer term, all diet approaches produce comparable results.
Intermittent fasting as a whole does not lead to greater weight loss in people with obesity than other diets or continuous calorie reduction. When it comes to body composition, there are small benefits: people who fast intermittently lose slightly more fat and over time have better blood sugar control than those who simply eat less. However, people who follow continuous calorie reduction feel less hungry and tired, and have lower triglycerides (fats in the blood). Intermittent fasting is an equally valid option, but not a clear winner.
Combining intermittent fasting with exercise produces noticeably more weight and fat loss than exercise alone: on average about 3 kg more weight loss, and less belly fat as well. So if you already exercise but are seeing little progress, adding an eating window may bring better results. If you add exercise to fasting (rather than fasting alone), your fitness improves noticeably, but fat and weight loss do not increase further as a result.
Time-restricted eating, such as limiting meals to an 8-hour window each day, appears to reduce both body weight and fat mass without losing muscle mass or hurting athletic performance. That is worth noting if you are physically active. If you also want to preserve muscle while losing weight, getting enough protein is a sensible addition. From research into high-protein diets for weight loss, the guidance for non-athletes with excess weight is: 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, for a minimum of 10 weeks and combined with strength training. That helps preserve muscle mass; it is not the type of protein (whey, soy, casein) but the total amount that matters.
Studies that directly combine intermittent fasting with a high protein intake and test weight loss as their main outcome are not present in the available evidence. What is clear is that fasting works best when paired with exercise, and that eating enough protein is worthwhile for preserving muscle. The data on the combined approach are limited, but early positive results in people do exist.
This answer draws on three summary studies of multiple earlier studies, two individual studies, and one review study. The researchers behind one of those summary studies rated the quality of the evidence as moderate. For time-restricted eating the data are thinner: that section rests on a smaller body of evidence where participants were not randomly assigned to groups. No study has tested the combination of intermittent fasting and a high protein intake together as a package specifically for weight loss.
Does extra protein help with losing weight without losing muscle?
Extra protein while losing weight helps: you lose slightly more fat and keep on average around 0.4 kg more muscle mass than on a normal-protein diet. Combine it with strength training for the best result.
Which form of intermittent fasting works best?
Alternate-day fasting has the strongest short-term evidence for weight loss, but the advantage over simply eating less is small and disappears after six months. Which approach suits you best depends on what you can sustain the longest.
Does intermittent fasting lower your cholesterol?
Intermittent fasting probably lowers total cholesterol and LDL modestly, but its effect on 'good' HDL cholesterol is unclear and long-term data are limited. It is a worthwhile strategy as a complement to, not a replacement for, proven treatments.
Does a fasting-mimicking diet work better than simply eating less?
Research suggests that a fasting-mimicking diet has a greater effect than the same calorie deficit without a fasting pattern. Bear in mind that almost all studies have ties to the commercial manufacturer.
Does intermittent fasting combined with high-protein eating help against belly fat?
Intermittent fasting combined with high-protein eating shows promising results for reducing deep belly fat. Add strength training to the mix and you have the best-supported combination if you also want to protect muscle mass.
Does fasting or intermittent fasting help prevent cancer?
Animal research into fasting and calorie restriction shows encouraging signals. In people, results from small studies are mixed.