How dangerous is poor fitness for your life expectancy?
Poor fitness is one of the strongest predictors of early death, comparable to well-known risk factors such as smoking. Every improvement in your fitness, however small, already makes a difference.
Poor fitness roughly doubles your chance of dying early. People with low fitness have a 53% higher risk of death than people with high fitness, measured across more than 20 million people followed across 199 studies. That puts poor fitness in the same company as smoking and high blood pressure as a risk factor.
The relationship works in steps: every small improvement counts. For each step up in endurance, roughly equivalent to being able to run about 1 kilometre per hour faster, your risk of death falls by 11 to 17 percent. You do not need to become a top athlete to gain something.
For heart disease the picture is even sharper. Poor fitness is associated with a 56% higher risk of heart problems. People who already have heart disease but are in good physical shape have an almost three times lower chance of dying from it than someone with the same condition but poor fitness. For heart failure specifically, the difference is even greater: people with good fitness develop it 69% less often.
Fitness also turns out to matter more than weight. People with poor fitness have roughly twice the risk of death, regardless of whether they have a normal weight, are overweight, or have obesity. Fit people who are overweight or even have obesity have a similar risk of death to fit people with a normal weight. That is not to say weight does not matter at all, but it does underline that moving more and building your fitness has a greater effect than simply watching the scales.
Muscle strength tells the same story. Lower hand-grip strength, a simple measure of overall muscle strength, is associated with higher death rates from all causes, heart disease, and cancer, in research involving more than three million participants. Even among people who already have cancer, those who are fitter show a 31 to 46 percent lower risk of death.
This answer draws on several large summaries combining tens to hundreds of studies with a total of tens of millions of people followed over time. The link between fitness and death is therefore one of the best-documented relationships in the health literature. These are people followed over time rather than experiments in which fitness was randomly assigned: a causal relationship is plausible but not definitively proven. For the question of whether exercise itself improves fitness, experimental evidence does exist, but the relevant source was not included in the supplied reference list and has therefore not been taken into account.