What is the TOTOX value of fish oil supplements?
Many fish oil supplements are more rancid than international standards allow and contain fewer active fatty acids than promised. Price and best-before date say nothing about this: choose a product with demonstrable quality control for oxidation.
The TOTOX value tells you how rancid a fish oil supplement is. It is calculated as twice the peroxide value plus the anisidine value. The peroxide value measures fresh oxidation, the anisidine value measures longer-standing breakdown products. Together they give a more complete picture than either number on its own. The international GOED standard sets the upper limit at 26.
In practice, that standard is regularly exceeded. Among 72 American omega-3 supplements, 68% of flavoured products had a TOTOX value that was too high; for unflavoured products the figure was 13%. In New Zealand, only 8% of 32 tested products simultaneously met all three oxidation standards. In South Africa, more than 80% of the supplements measured in both 2009 and 2012 had a peroxide value that was too high. Price, best-before date and country of origin turned out to be no reliable indicators of quality. When buying, therefore, pay attention to the label: look for products that state demonstrable, independent quality control for oxidation, such as a TOTOX value below 26 or certification by a third party.
In addition to excessive oxidation values, most products also contain fewer active fatty acids than the label promises. In New Zealand, 69% of products contained less than two thirds of the stated amount of EPA and DHA. In South Africa, the same applied to more than half. So you sometimes get less of what you want and more of what you do not want. Whether a product is flavoured or unflavoured does matter: flavoured products were more often rancid.
Whether rancid fish oil is actually harmful to humans is difficult to establish conclusively. Animal studies show harm from oxidised fats, but clinical studies in humans have rarely reported the oxidation status of the oils being tested. The potential risks are biologically plausible but not clinically proven. Oxidation products such as aldehydes cause the familiar fishy smell and taste, one of the reasons people avoid supplements.
Claims based on market surveys conducted in the United States, New Zealand, South Africa and the UAE, plus a review on oxidation and health effects. No randomised trials; evidence for health harm in humans is limited to animal studies and associative studies.
How much taurine do you need per day?
There is no established daily figure for taurine alone. Anyone who regularly eats fish, meat or dairy is probably getting enough. A supplement is unnecessary for healthy people and is not recommended.
Do antioxidant supplements make sense?
For healthy people, antioxidant supplements such as beta-carotene and vitamin E are not useful as protection against cancer or heart disease, and beta-carotene is frankly inadvisable for (ex-)smokers. The only well-supported exception is the AREDS formula for advanced macular degeneration: discuss this with your ophthalmologist.
How much lithium do you need each day?
There is no official daily recommendation for lithium; scientists cite 1 mg per day as a cautious guideline, but evidence for benefits in healthy people is largely absent, so supplementation is not yet substantiated.
Are seed oils like sunflower oil bad for you?
Seed oils like sunflower oil are probably not outright harmful, but cannot be given an unconditional clean bill of health either: ideally, also make sure your diet includes enough omega-3-rich foods such as oily fish or flaxseed to keep the ratio in balance.
Can you take too much fish oil?
At high pharmaceutical doses of fish oil (1,800 to 4,000 mg per day) the risk of an irregular heartbeat rises measurably; at the amounts most people take daily, the risks are small and there are instead signs of modest heart protection.
Do fish oil pills keep my memory sharp?
Fish oil may make a modest contribution to attention and memory, but the evidence is not strong enough to recommend a pill over a varied, fish-rich dietary pattern.