longevitywatch
← All podcasts

Dr. Mindy Pelz

hosted by Mindy Pelz

We tested 254 claims from Dr. Mindy Pelz against the research. 16 held up, 48 did not, and the rest are partly true or still too early to judge.

We only test the claims that can be checked, not everything that is said. This is not a ranking.

Mindy Pelz · hosts Dr. Mindy Pelz

American chiropractor, author and speaker on fasting and hormones

Partly
“Weight loss is a hormonal process in which lowering insulin levels causes the body to burn fat more effectively.”
Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and speaker on fasting and hormones) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Insulin plays a role in fat storage and fat metabolism, and excess weight is indeed associated with insulin resistance, which decreases when weight is lost. However, the claim that weight loss is purely a hormonal process in which lowering insulin is the key goes beyond what the evidence justifies. Research shows that losing weight works through exercise, diet, and a combination of both, and that the approach matters less than sticking with it. Insulin is one factor in this, not the overriding mechanism.
Partly
“People with strong social relationships have a 50 percent greater chance of survival compared to people with weak relationships”
Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and speaker on fasting and hormones) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Social contact is indeed associated with a longer lifespan, and this relationship has been found in multiple observational studies. The figure of 50 percent greater survival odds cannot be substantiated based on the research we are aware of: the size of the effect varies between studies, between types of contact and between sexes, and quality turns out to matter more than quantity. Moreover, all the studies involved are observational, which means that cause and effect are not certain.
Partly
“The abdomen contains the most cortisol receptors, which means that chronic stress without exercise leads to fat storage around the belly”
Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and speaker on fasting and hormones) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That chronic stress leads to the accumulation of deep abdominal fat via cortisol is well-supported: multiple studies confirm this link, through hormonal pathways as well as behaviours such as reduced physical activity and poorer sleep. The claim that the abdomen contains the most cortisol receptors is the weak link: that specific mechanism is not firmly established in the available research, and abdominal fat accumulation is explained through broader pathways than receptor numbers alone. Exercise certainly plays a role, but the claim presents the absence of exercise as the decisive factor, whereas cortisol also promotes abdominal fat through diet, sleep and other behavioural factors.
Partly
“Fasting is the best way to stimulate autophagy in the body”
Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and speaker on fasting and hormones) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Fasting demonstrably stimulates autophagy, including in multiple organs and tissues in humans. However, it is not the only way: exercise also triggers autophagy in muscle cells through well-described mechanisms, and caloric restriction is likewise a well-supported route. The claim that fasting is the "best" way goes beyond what the research shows, as there is no comparative evidence that fasting outperforms other methods.

Dr. Mindy Pelz

Chiropractor, author and online health coach specialising in fasting and hormones in women

Partly
“At least 10 minutes of contact with nature significantly lowers cortisol levels.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and online health coach specialising in fasting and hormones in women) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Walking in green spaces has a demonstrably positive effect on mental health, and short-term stress raises cortisol through the stress system. However, the specific claim that at least 10 minutes of contact with nature significantly lowers cortisol levels cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research. The general direction is plausible, but the precise threshold of 10 minutes and the word "significantly" go beyond what current research supports.
Partly
“Time-restricted eating with an eating window of 4 to 6 hours does not lead to significant changes in oestrogen, progesterone or testosterone in pre- and postmenopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and health influencer specialising in fasting for women) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A review of six studies shows that time-restricted eating in overweight women does indeed not cause any clear changes in testosterone, oestrogen or progesterone. The claim is therefore correct for that group. However, in women with the hormonal condition PCOS, in which the ovaries do not function properly and hormones are out of balance, non-randomised studies did find hormonal changes, such as a decrease in testosterone. Moreover, the claim specifically concerns an eating window of 4 to 6 hours in both pre- and postmenopausal women, whereas the research focuses mainly on overweight women or women with PCOS and does not always examine that specific eating window or compare both groups of women. Ramadan fasting, which follows a different pattern from a strict 4-to-6-hour eating window, did show a clear decrease in oestrogen in premenopausal women. The evidence is therefore too limited and too inconsistent to fully support the claim.
Partly
“Snacking continuously throughout the day keeps insulin levels constantly high, so the body never enters a state of low insulin.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and advocate of intermittent fasting and functional nutrition) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Eating and snacking frequently does indeed keep insulin levels elevated compared to periods without eating: that is consistent with what research shows about how fasting and time-restricted eating lower fasting insulin. However, the claim goes beyond the evidence by stating that insulin therefore remains "constantly high" and that the body "never" enters a low-insulin state. Research looks at the direction of the effect, not at such an absolute threshold. Moreover, the timing of eating turns out to be at least as important a factor as frequency.
Partly
“After 12 hours of fasting, the production of growth hormone is stimulated, which promotes fat burning.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and advocate of intermittent fasting and functional nutrition) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
Fasting does indeed trigger brief growth hormone peaks through a well-known physiological signal, but the claim goes beyond the evidence on two points. First, it mentions a specific threshold of 12 hours, whereas research does not confirm that boundary so clearly. Second, it suggests that higher growth hormone levels promote fat burning in the longer term, but small randomised studies actually show that six weeks of daily fasting produces no measurable increase in growth hormone or IGF-1 levels in the blood. The acute pulse effect is the most concrete effect you can expect, not a sustained fat-burning benefit.
Partly
“A drop in oestrogen levels leads to increased insulin resistance and promotes fat storage around the abdomen.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and advocate of intermittent fasting and functional nutrition) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several review studies in both humans and animals show that a drop in oestrogen is associated with greater insulin resistance and a shift in fat storage towards the abdominal region. One review describes how oestrogen deficiency leads to impaired insulin sensitivity in muscles, the liver and adipose tissue, while another links the decline in oestrogen during menopause to increased abdominal fat and a higher risk of metabolic syndrome. The direction of the claim is therefore correct, but the relationship is more complex than the claim suggests: the reviews emphasise that the precise contribution of oestrogen loss to fat storage in women has not yet been fully elucidated, and that other factors such as age and lifestyle also play a role.
Partly
“Every 5-centimetre (2-inch) increase in waist circumference raises the risk of premature death by approximately 17% in men and 13% in women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and presenter) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A large study pooling the results of 72 long-running population studies involving more than 2.5 million participants shows that a larger waist circumference is associated with a higher risk of death. However, the figures of 17% (men) and 13% (women) do not match the published data. That study reports an increase of 11% for every 10-centimetre increase in waist circumference, without making a separate distinction between men and women for this figure. Another study involving very elderly people (average age 90) finds an increase of approximately 11% per 5-centimetre increase in waist circumference, but this concerns a specific, older Chinese population. The main conclusion is therefore correct, but the precise percentages and the distinction by sex cannot be found in the research. → How dangerous is belly fat?
✗ Does not hold up
“At a 1:1 ratio of omega-3 to omega-6 fatty acids, the body does not produce visceral fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and presenter) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in rats shows that a 1:1 ratio of omega-3 to omega-6 is associated with less abdominal fat and a lower body weight compared to a diet high in saturated fat or a ratio in which omega-3 is strongly underrepresented. However, "less abdominal fat" is very different from "producing no abdominal fat at all". Moreover, this evidence comes from animal research, and the only relevant study in humans that measured abdominal fat (in children of mothers who took supplements) found no clear difference in the amount of abdominal fat. The claim that the body produces no abdominal fat at a 1:1 ratio is therefore unsubstantiated and is contradicted by the available research.
✗ Does not hold up
“After 16 hours of fasting, white visceral fat begins to transform into brown fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and presenter) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The answers confirm that white and brown fat differ fundamentally from each other, but the research identifies cold exposure, not fasting, as a proven way to activate brown fat. A specific threshold of 16 hours of fasting as a driver of that conversion has not been demonstrated, and there is no substantiation for the idea that visceral white fat transforms into brown fat in humans through fasting. The claim combines two elements, fasting and brown fat formation, in a way that the available evidence does not support.
✗ Does not hold up
“Visceral fat is primarily caused by omega-6 fats from industrial seed oils.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and presenter) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Visceral fat is an active tissue that sends inflammatory substances and fatty acids to the liver, thereby increasing the risk of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. As for what primarily causes it, research points to a broader combination of factors: overeating and insufficient physical activity are central to this. Singling out omega-6 fats from industrial seed oils as the main cause goes beyond what the available evidence supports. That specific claim has not been demonstrated.
Partly
“Coffee stimulates autophagy within one to four hours of consumption.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (American chiropractor, author and health influencer specialising in fasting for women) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There is mechanistic evidence suggesting that caffeine can activate a cellular clean-up process, but the translation to everyday coffee consumption in healthy people has not yet been made. The specific time window of one to four hours is not supported by the research: no established threshold or timeline for coffee-induced autophagy in humans has been determined. The claim sounds more concrete than the evidence allows.
Partly
“Compressing the eating window to 8 hours a day (16 hours of fasting) improves insulin sensitivity and blood pressure without any change in total calorie intake.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and online health coach specialising in fasting and hormones in women) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Multiple studies show that intermittent fasting improves insulin sensitivity and lowers fasting insulin levels, which supports the core of the claim. For blood pressure, the evidence is less direct in this context: studies point to broader cardiovascular benefits, but a specific effect on blood pressure independent of weight loss has not been firmly established. The crucial issue lies in calorie intake: a direct comparison between time-restricted eating and conventional calorie reduction is still lacking, so it has not been established that the effects occur without any change in what or how much you eat.
Partly
“A light walk of 10 to 15 minutes after a meal lowers the postprandial glucose response.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and online health coach specialising in fasting and hormones in women) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
A walk after a meal does indeed lower the blood sugar peak, and this has been confirmed by multiple randomised studies and meta-analyses. Notably, however, short walking breaks of 2 to 3 minutes spread throughout the day appear to be more effective than a single uninterrupted walk afterwards. The claim implies that a 10-to-15-minute walk is the best approach, but the evidence points more towards frequent short breaks. In addition, little research has been conducted in healthy people with a normal body weight.
Too early
“Daily fibre supplementation reduces visceral fat and waist circumference compared to a placebo.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and advocate of fasting and ketogenic lifestyles) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Individual studies on fibre supplementation and waist circumference show modest results, but I was unable to find a convincing comprehensive analysis specifically on visceral fat. Visceral fat is also difficult to measure: it requires a scan, and many studies use waist circumference as a proxy, which is not the same thing.
Partly
“Eating 25 grams of fibre a day slows digestion, stabilises blood sugar levels and suppresses appetite.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and advocate of fasting and ketogenic lifestyles) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
The direction is correct: fiber slows gastric emptying, dampens blood sugar spikes, and promotes satiety. However, it depends strongly on which type of fiber. Randomized studies show that some fibers increase satiety without affecting blood sugar, and vice versa. The threshold of 25 grams is a general dietary guideline, not a measured tipping point above which these effects kick in.
Partly
“HIIT training at 70% of VO2 max stimulates growth hormone production and accelerates fat burning.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and advocate of fasting and ketogenic lifestyles) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
That interval training increases growth hormone release has been genuinely measured; the effect is so reliable that it is even used as a test for growth hormone deficiency. Two caveats, though. Seventy percent of VO2 max is not a high intensity but rather solid endurance work. And the leap from higher growth hormone levels to faster fat burning is greater than it sounds: that peak is short-lived and its contribution to daily fat use is small.
Partly
“Fasting stimulates the conversion of white adipose tissue into brown adipose tissue.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and advocate of fasting and ketogenic lifestyles) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There is research showing this, but in mice. In those studies, white adipose tissue does indeed shift towards brown fat under the influence of fasting, partly via the gut microbiome. In humans, brown fat is far scarcer and harder to measure, and it has not been shown that fasting activates it in us as well.
✗ Does not hold up
“Fasting once a week for 24 hours resets the metabolism.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and advocate of fasting and ketogenic lifestyles) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
'Resetting the metabolism' is not something measurable. There is no switch that flips and no default state to return to. What going without food for a full day does do is draw on glycogen stores and increase fat burning, but those effects are gone again the following day.
✓ Holds up
“Intermittent fasting during Ramadan leads to reductions in body weight, BMI, waist circumference and fat mass.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Correct. Review studies on Ramadan fasting consistently find small decreases in weight, BMI, waist circumference and fat mass. There is, however, an important caveat that usually accompanies this finding: most of these changes have disappeared again within a few weeks after Ramadan.
Too early
“Exogenous ketones can serve as an alternative energy source for the brain in conditions with impaired glucose metabolism, such as Alzheimer's disease or after brain injury.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
That the brain can use ketones as fuel is correct and well established. The next step remains an open question: in Alzheimer's disease, small studies using ketones or MCT oil sometimes show a modest improvement, particularly in people without the APOE4 gene, but the studies are small and short-term. As a treatment, this is not substantiated; as a research direction, it is taken seriously.
Partly
“Adding MCT oil to breakfast increases satiety and reduces subsequent calorie intake.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There are small studies in which people ate somewhat less at the next meal after consuming MCT oil. The effects are modest, have not been found in every study, and were measured over a single day. There is no evidence to support long-term weight loss.
Partly
“The body is more sensitive to insulin in the morning and becomes increasingly insulin-resistant as it grows darker, driven by melatonin patterns.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is established that insulin sensitivity is highest in the morning and declines throughout the day. The explanation via melatonin is plausible and partly supported by evidence, since melatonin suppresses insulin secretion, but it is one of several factors and not the whole explanation.
✓ Holds up
“Skipping breakfast leads to a higher blood sugar and insulin response after meals later in the day.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Correct, and this is better studied than many people think. If you skip breakfast, your body responds to the next meal with a higher blood sugar and insulin spike than it would if you had eaten breakfast. This effect is called the second-meal effect.
Too early
“Not eating or drinking for twelve hours can increase the production of BDNF (brain-derived neurotrophic factor) in the brain.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
In animal studies, fasting demonstrably raises levels of this growth factor in the brain. In humans, this has barely been studied, and the measurements that do exist contradict one another. For a period of twelve hours specifically, there is no evidence whatsoever.
Partly
“Fasting from sunrise to sunset reduces various pro-inflammatory cytokines in adults with an elevated BMI.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Some studies do observe reductions in inflammatory markers after a period of sunrise-to-sunset fasting. However, many things change at once during that period: eating patterns, sleep, and often body weight as well. Which of these factors is responsible for the effect cannot be determined from this research.
Partly
“Dry fasting leads to faster weight loss and a faster transition into ketosis than water fasting.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz (Chiropractor, author and expert in fasting) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · shared as personal experience
The scales do move faster, but that is largely water rather than fat: without drinking, you can easily lose a kilogram or more of water in a single day, which returns as soon as you drink again. The claim that ketosis is reached more quickly has not been demonstrated. Dry fasting also carries a real risk of dehydration and kidney strain.

Dr. Ben Bikman

Professor and expert in metabolic health

Partly
“A rise in cortisol levels makes the body directly more insulin resistant”
Dr. Ben Bikman (Professor and expert in metabolic health) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Cortisol and insulin resistance are demonstrably linked, but the evidence in the research concerns chronically elevated cortisol, not a brief rise. With prolonged excessive cortisol levels, several mechanisms have been described that lead to the accumulation of deep abdominal fat and insulin resistance. The word 'directly' in the claim suggests an immediate effect with every rise in cortisol, whereas research shows that this is a process that develops over a longer period of time. The direction is correct, then, but the claim makes it sharper and faster than the evidence justifies.
Partly
“Fermentation of carbohydrates reduces the amount of digestible glucose and breaks down antinutrients such as phytates and tannins considerably”
Dr. Ben Bikman (Professor and expert in metabolic health) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Fermentation does indeed improve the digestibility of food, and this is supported by research into fermented products. However, the specific claim that carbohydrates yield less digestible glucose during fermentation and that phytates and tannins are broken down considerably goes beyond what the available evidence concretely shows: it focuses on broader effects such as antioxidant activity and overall digestibility, not on these individual mechanisms. The general direction of the claim is plausible, but the precise details regarding antinutrients and glucose content cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research.
✗ Does not hold up
“An insulin spike from carbohydrates combined with a large amount of fat strongly stimulates an increase in body fat”
Dr. Ben Bikman (Professor and expert in metabolic health) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The ratio of fat to carbohydrates in a meal makes little difference to weight gain in the long term, as long as total calorie intake remains the same. This is shown by multiple randomised studies and meta-analyses. The claim that an insulin spike combined with a high fat intake strongly promotes fat storage goes beyond what the research supports: total caloric surplus is the determining factor, not the specific combination of macronutrients. The idea that fat is stored extra rapidly in the presence of insulin has not been demonstrated as a mechanism that operates independently of energy balance.
Partly
“Oestrogen stimulates the female body to burn more fat than men do.”
Dr. Ben Bikman (metabolic scientist) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans does indeed show that women burn proportionally more fat during endurance exercise than men, and that this difference disappears after the menopause when oestrogen levels fall, which suggests that oestrogen plays a role. However, the evidence that oestrogen directly causes this higher rate of fat burning is less solid: one review study reports that oestrogen supplements produce less convincing results in humans than in rodents, and a human study with 36 participants was unable to explain the sex difference in fat burning during exercise on the basis of proteins measured in muscle and fat tissue. The claim that oestrogen drives the female body to burn more fat is therefore broadly correct, but the underlying mechanism in humans has not yet been fully elucidated and the role of oestrogen is less straightforward than the claim suggests.
✗ Does not hold up
“During the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle, women are to some extent insulin resistant and less tolerant of carbohydrates.”
Dr. Ben Bikman (metabolic scientist) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several studies in healthy women without diabetes find no clear difference in blood sugar regulation or insulin sensitivity between the luteal and follicular phases. A study of 110 women found no difference in blood sugar levels or the amount of insulin the body produces after consuming a sugary drink, and a study of 13 healthy women likewise found no clear difference in how well the body responds to insulin between the two phases. Research in young women also confirms that the way the body processes carbohydrates does not change noticeably across the cycle. Only in women with type 1 diabetes is there any indication that some of them may be slightly less sensitive to insulin during the luteal phase, but even there the evidence is not unequivocal and the quality of the studies is limited.
Partly
“Progesterone acts as a hunger hormone that stimulates the brain to eat.”
Dr. Ben Bikman (metabolic scientist) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in women and female rats shows that progesterone can stimulate appetite, and a review article on women also explicitly mentions this. Nevertheless, the picture is not clear-cut: a study in female rats without ovaries actually shows that progesterone reduces food intake and body weight. The effect appears to be strongly dependent on the hormonal context, such as the presence of oestrogen. Furthermore, progesterone does not act directly as a 'hunger hormone' in the brain the way ghrelin does; rather, it indirectly influences other signalling substances in the brain that regulate hunger.
Partly
“A high blood sugar level activates the sympathetic nervous system.”
Dr. Ben Bikman (metabolic scientist) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
What research actually shows is the opposite: low blood sugar activates stress hormones and the sympathetic nervous system, not high blood sugar. In hypoglycaemia, stress hormones rise and symptoms such as trembling and sweating occur, which are typical of sympathetic activation. Whether a high blood sugar level triggers the same mechanism cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research. So the direction of the claim is wrong, even though blood sugar and the autonomic nervous system do genuinely interact.
Partly
“After menopause, the female brain becomes more insulin resistant due to the loss of oestrogen.”
Dr. Ben Bikman (metabolic scientist) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that oestrogen plays an important role in regulating glucose metabolism in the brain, and that the loss of oestrogen around menopause is associated with reduced energy metabolism in the brain and an increased risk of insulin resistance. A study of 260 people, including 165 women, also found that postmenopausal women had lower insulin sensitivity in the hippocampus, but that this was linked to an unhealthy fat distribution and was not attributed directly to oestrogen loss alone. The direction of the claim is therefore correct, but the evidence for a direct causal chain specifically from oestrogen loss to insulin resistance in the brain comes largely from animal and laboratory studies and review articles, while the human data point to an unfavourable fat distribution as an intermediate factor. The claim oversimplifies matters by presenting oestrogen loss as the direct and sole cause.

Dr. David Perlmutter

Neurologist and bestselling author

Partly
“Physical exercise can increase the volume of the hippocampus and improve memory.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
This refers to a well-known study in which older adults who did a year of aerobic training ended up with a slightly larger memory centre, by around two percent. That finding is real, but later and larger studies did not consistently replicate the effect on volume. That exercise is good for your brain is well established; growth of the hippocampus is less certain.
Partly
“The use of GLP-1 agonists in diabetic patients is linked to a 40% reduction in the risk of developing Alzheimer's disease.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
This is one of the most exciting research directions at the moment, and the general finding points in the right direction: in large patient databases, diabetic patients taking GLP-1 medications develop dementia less often. However, this is observational research, not a trial, and that is precisely where a key problem arises: those who receive these medications are often better treated and more closely monitored. The randomised trials needed to settle the question are still ongoing, and the first results are expected within a few years.
Partly
“The risk of Alzheimer's disease starts to increase already at an HbA1c value of around 5.8%.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There is research showing that the relationship between long-term blood sugar levels and cognitive decline extends below the diabetes threshold, without a clear cut-off point. That is a genuine and interesting observation. But precisely for that reason, there is no tipping point at 5.8 percent; that figure suggests a threshold that the research does not support.
Partly
“Type 2 diabetes can increase the risk of developing Alzheimer's disease by as much as threefold.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with caution
Type 2 diabetes demonstrably increases the risk of dementia, but the pooled estimate from review studies puts it at roughly one and a half to two times the baseline risk. A threefold increase is the upper end of what a single study has ever found, and presenting that as the figure makes the risk appear greater than it is. The underlying point still stands: your blood sugar matters for your brain.
✓ Holds up
“Two thirds of all cases of Alzheimer's disease affect women.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Correct: roughly two in three people with Alzheimer's are women. However, the explanation that usually goes with this figure is missing here: women live longer on average, and age is by far the greatest risk factor. Whether something specifically female also plays a role, for instance related to menopause, is being investigated but has not been established.
Partly
“An elevated waist-to-hip ratio and excess abdominal fat are a strong risk factor for Alzheimer's disease.”
Dr. David Perlmutter (Neurologist and bestselling author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Abdominal fat in middle age is associated with a higher risk of dementia later in life; this has been found repeatedly in population studies. That said, calling it a strong risk factor is an overstatement: the association is modest and likely runs mostly through blood pressure, glucose metabolism, and inflammation. It is not a standalone cause.

Dr. Sarah Myhill

British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism

Partly
“Microbes that leak into the bloodstream through a leaky gut can cause joint inflammation, fibromyalgia, asthma or hives.”
Dr. Sarah Myhill (British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A disrupted intestinal barrier can, through excessive permeability of the gut wall, fuel low-grade inflammation throughout the body, and that association with chronic conditions is consistently visible in research. However, whether those microbes directly cause specific diseases such as fibromyalgia, asthma or hives has not been demonstrated in humans. For most of these conditions, researchers do not yet know whether the gut microbiota is the cause or the consequence. The claim presents an indirect and as yet unproven mechanism as established causality, which goes beyond what the evidence currently supports.
✗ Does not hold up
“A woman's waist circumference should be 80 centimetres or less; anything above that indicates fat accumulation caused by fermentation in the upper intestine.”
Dr. Sarah Myhill (British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A waist circumference above 80 centimetres is indeed considered to indicate an elevated risk for women, but that threshold is associated with a greater risk of cardiovascular disease and diabetes due to visceral fat around the organs. That visceral fat is not caused by fermentation in the upper intestine: research points to metabolism, hormonal regulation and inflammatory processes as the explanatory mechanisms. The idea of "fat accumulation caused by fermentation in the upper intestine" has not been demonstrated and contradicts what we know about abdominal fat.
✗ Does not hold up
“Dementia can be prevented in 99 percent of cases with a ketogenic diet, lowering homocysteine and eating fatty fish”
Dr. Sarah Myhill (British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that lifestyle can reduce the risk of dementia, but that is something very different from preventing 99 percent of cases. That precise percentage cannot be substantiated, and evidence for a specific ketogenic diet or lowering homocysteine as a preventive measure is absent from the available research. What does have some support is eating fish as part of a broader healthy diet, such as the Mediterranean or MIND diet, which is associated with a modest risk reduction of 16 to 28 %. The claim that dementia is preventable for almost everyone with these three approaches goes far beyond what research has shown so far.
Partly
“Ketones suppress hunger”
Dr. Sarah Myhill (British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several review studies and human trials show that a ketogenic diet restrains the rise in the hunger hormone ghrelin that normally occurs with weight loss, and that people feel less hungry. However, two recent well-designed randomised trials conducted in people with obesity found no clear difference in hunger between groups with higher or lower ketone levels. One study also concludes that mildly elevated ketones are not enough to noticeably suppress hunger. The claim is therefore broadly correct in its direction, but research shows that the effect does not always occur and may depend on how deep the ketosis is and whether weight loss is already taking place.
✓ Holds up
“Thyroid hormones are necessary for normal fat burning”
Dr. Sarah Myhill (British doctor and author specialising in chronic fatigue and metabolism) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The thyroid hormones T3 and T4 regulate how quickly your body burns energy, and when levels are too low, that burning process demonstrably slows down. The claim that these hormones are necessary for normal fat burning is also indirectly supported by research into caloric restriction: when T3 production temporarily drops, the body noticeably adjusts its energy expenditure. The claim is therefore well in line with what research shows.

Dr. Jason Fung

Nephrologist, author and expert in fasting and metabolic health

Partly
“Fasting and low-carbohydrate diets reduce liver fat and visceral fat selectively and much faster than total body fat percentage.”
Dr. Jason Fung (Nephrologist, author and expert in fasting and metabolic health) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that eating low-carb noticeably reduces belly fat and liver fat, and that this effect occurs relatively quickly, especially in people who are overweight or have metabolic complaints. However, the claim that this happens "selectively" and "much faster" than the loss of total body fat goes beyond what the available research firmly establishes: studies show a beneficial effect on belly fat, but a direct comparison with the rate of total body fat percentage loss is not demonstrated in those studies. Moreover, the weight-loss advantage of low-carbohydrate diets over other diets largely disappears over time, which puts the emphasis on "much faster" into perspective.
✗ Does not hold up
“Fasting does not lead to muscle loss in people with sufficient fat reserves; muscle breakdown is caused primarily by inactivity.”
Dr. Jason Fung (Nephrologist and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Both animal and human studies show that fasting does lead to muscle loss, even when sufficient fat reserves are still present. Research in rats shows that muscle proteins are broken down during fasting, and that fat burning only partially and temporarily slows this process. A study in healthy men shows that after ten days of fasting, both fat and muscle tissue are lost, with protein breakdown occurring mainly in the first few days. Moreover, research shows that fasting itself, in addition to physical inactivity, is an independent cause of muscle breakdown through specific breakdown mechanisms in muscle tissue.
Partly
“Fasting preferentially targets the breakdown of visceral fat compared to subcutaneous fat.”
Dr. Jason Fung (Nephrologist and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that lifestyle changes, including fasting and caloric restriction, reduce visceral fat more quickly than subcutaneous fat. It is therefore correct that visceral fat is more susceptible to breakdown through these kinds of interventions. However, the claim states that fasting does this "preferentially" compared to subcutaneous fat, which suggests that a deliberate selection takes place; the evidence rather describes a difference in the rate of loss, not an active selection mechanism specific to fasting. Whether this also applies specifically to fasting and not to caloric restriction in general cannot be distinguished on the basis of the available research.
Partly
“Carbohydrates stimulate insulin, whereas proteins specifically raise the nutrient sensor mTOR.”
Dr. Jason Fung (Nephrologist and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The claim that carbohydrates stimulate insulin is correct and well supported: reducing carbohydrates and eating a low-glycaemic diet demonstrably improves insulin regulation. The second part of the claim, that proteins specifically raise mTOR, is not substantiated by the available information. mTOR is described in research as a nutrient sensor, but the assertion that protein intake specifically raises this sensor cannot be firmly established in humans on the basis of the available evidence.
Partly
“Oestrogen suppresses appetite and directs fat to subcutaneous tissues, while a decline during menopause leads to increased appetite and storage of visceral fat.”
Dr. Jason Fung (Nephrologist, author and expert in fasting and metabolic health) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research clearly confirms that declining oestrogen levels during menopause are associated with greater fat accumulation in the abdominal area (visceral fat) and a worsening body composition. This link is well supported. However, the specific mechanism by which oestrogen suppresses appetite and actively directs fat to subcutaneous tissues, and by which a decline reverses this exactly, goes beyond what available research can establish with certainty: the shift towards abdominal fat is well documented, but the precise role of appetite suppression in this process cannot be firmly established.

Laila Ali

Former world boxing champion, author and wellness advocate

Too early
“During the refeeding phase after a period of fasting, muscle tissue can grow back more strongly than with traditional dieting.”
Laila Ali (Former world boxing champion, author and wellness advocate) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into muscle protein synthesis during the refeeding phase has so far been conducted almost exclusively in animals such as rats, mice, chicks and livestock. Those studies show that protein synthesis in muscles rises sharply after fasting when food is reintroduced, and that growing animals temporarily build up extra lean tissue. In mice that had already lost muscle mass through inactivity beforehand, the muscle turned out to respond less well to refeeding. Whether muscle tissue in humans grows back more strongly after fasting than with normal dieting has not yet been tested in humans in the available studies.
✗ Does not hold up
“During perimenopause, muscle breakdown accelerates regardless of training efforts.”
Laila Ali (Former world boxing champion, author and wellness advocate) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that muscle loss is indeed a risk with aging, but exercise does genuinely help to counter it. Regular strength training, combined with adequate protein intake, is the best-supported approach to preventing muscle loss, even at an older age. The claim that muscle breakdown accelerates regardless of training efforts is therefore incorrect: training makes a demonstrable difference. Specific evidence on perimenopause as a distinct phase in relation to muscle breakdown is lacking in the available research.
✓ Holds up
“The drop in oestrogen during the perimenopause leads to an increase in visceral fat.”
Laila Ali (Former world boxing champion, author and wellness advocate) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Declining estrogen levels during perimenopause do indeed promote the accumulation of visceral abdominal fat. Observational and mechanistic research shows that hormones and abdominal fat reinforce each other's effects: lower estrogen promotes fat deposits around the abdomen, and that abdominal fat in turn further disrupts metabolism. The relationship is reasonably well supported, although large controlled trials that conclusively prove causality are lacking.

Dr. Dan Siegel

Professor of psychiatry and author

Partly
“Oestrogen stimulates substances in the brain such as dopamine, serotonin, acetylcholine, oxytocin and BDNF.”
Dr. Dan Siegel (Professor of psychiatry and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That oestrogen plays a role in how the brain functions, including in substances that influence mood and cognition, is supported by research: studies on memory and concentration show that a declining oestrogen level has measurable effects on brain function. However, the claim names a specific series of substances, including dopamine, serotonin, acetylcholine, oxytocin and BDNF, and that precise list cannot be substantiated on the basis of available research. Moreover, "stimulates" suggests a straightforwardly upward effect, whereas in reality the picture depends on factors such as timing, type of oestrogen and individual circumstances.
Partly
“An attention training based on focused attention, open awareness and kind intention lowers cortisol levels and improves cardiovascular health and the immune system.”
Dr. Dan Siegel (Professor of psychiatry and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that mindfulness and meditation can generally lower cortisol and may influence the immune system, but the claim goes further than the evidence supports on one important point. A large randomised study with 313 participants actually shows that focused attention training does not lower the cortisol stress response, whereas social forms of training such as compassion training do. At the same time, meta-analyses show that mindfulness and meditation as a broad category positively influence cortisol and some heart-related measures, and that effects on the immune system are still small and mixed. The combination of focused attention, open awareness and kind intention has not been tested as a package in the available studies, and the claimed effects do not apply equally to all three components. → How healthy is meditation, and what does it actually do for you?
Partly
“A meditation exercise with three pillars optimises the enzyme telomerase to repair telomeres, thereby slowing the biological ageing process.”
Dr. Dan Siegel (Professor of psychiatry and author) · Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Meditation increases telomerase activity across multiple randomised studies, most likely through stress reduction, and this is consistent with the idea that it can influence ageing at the cellular level. However, whether telomeres themselves actually grow longer as a result of meditation has not yet been demonstrated, and the studies are too small to draw firm conclusions. The claim that a specific exercise with "three pillars" optimises telomerase and thereby slows the biological ageing process goes beyond what research has shown so far: the mechanistic chain from meditation to telomere length to a slowing of ageing has not been conclusively proven.

From the episodes, no speaker named

Partly
“After the age of forty, muscle protein synthesis slows down, causing muscle recovery after exercise to take longer.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that the muscles of older adults respond less well to nutrition and exercise than those of younger people, a phenomenon known as 'anabolic resistance'. This means that muscle protein synthesis rises less strongly in response to a stimulus, not necessarily that it is lower at rest. The claim that this already occurs from the age of forty is not quite accurate: studies refer to 'middle age' as the starting point of muscle loss, but link the reduced synthesis response to ageing in general rather than specifically to the age of forty. Moreover, the studies focus on the reduced anabolic response to protein and exercise, whereas the claim is specifically about longer muscle recovery after exercise, which is a somewhat different claim that is not directly tested as such. → How much rest do my muscles need between workouts as I get older?
Partly
“Eating at least 30 grams of protein at the first meal after fasting stimulates muscle growth and helps prevent muscle loss.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Eating enough protein does indeed help maintain muscle mass, including around periods of fasting, and total daily intake is the strongest factor in this. Research suggests that 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight per day is more effective than the minimum guideline, combined with strength training. However, the threshold of exactly 30 grams per meal cannot be firmly established based on the available evidence, and timing appears less decisive than the daily total. The claim singles out one specific meal, while the research emphasises what you consume throughout the entire day.
Partly
“After menopause, the drop in oestrogen causes anabolic resistance, meaning muscles need a greater stimulus from protein and strength training to grow.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Menopause is indeed accompanied by a drop in oestrogen that leads to accelerated muscle mass loss and a less favourable body composition, and both protein intake and strength training are well supported as ways to limit this. However, the claim goes further by explicitly invoking "anabolic resistance" as the mechanism: the evidence available does not firmly establish that oestrogen loss works through this specific mechanism and therefore requires higher thresholds for protein and training than before menopause. The direction of the recommendation, more protein and strength training after menopause, is plausible, but the underlying mechanism is presented as more certain than the evidence allows.
✗ Does not hold up
“MCT oil switches off the hunger signal in the brain.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several studies in humans show that MCT oil does not clearly affect feelings of hunger and satiety compared to other fats. A large analysis combining seventeen separate studies concludes that while MCT can slightly reduce the amount of food eaten, it has no measurable effect on feelings of hunger or on the hormones that regulate appetite. One study found no difference at all in how much people ate or how full they felt, compared to other fats. The claim that MCT oil "switches off" the hunger signal in the brain therefore goes beyond what the research shows: there is no evidence in humans for a direct effect on the hunger signal in the brain, and the effects on eating behaviour are limited and highly variable.
Partly
“Taking MCT oil on an empty stomach causes a significant rise in blood ketones that peaks at 60 minutes.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
One study in 19 healthy adults does indeed show that MCT oil on an empty stomach measurably raises blood ketone levels, with a peak at 60 minutes. That supports the claim. However, that study also compared MCT oil with MCT oil combined with glucose, and that peak applied specifically to that condition. Other studies measure at different time points or show that the peak depends strongly on the type of MCT oil and the circumstances, such as the presence of caffeine or the type of fatty acid. The claim gives the impression that this is a general rule that applies to all MCT oil, whereas the evidence shows that the timing of the peak and the size of the rise vary considerably depending on the type of MCT and the situation.
Partly
“The fibres in legumes feed gut bacteria that stimulate the production of the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The idea that fibres in legumes feed beneficial gut bacteria is well supported: fructans and galacto-oligosaccharides, which are also found in legumes, reliably stimulate bacteria such as Bifidobacterium. The step from that bacterial activity to increased GLP-1 production is promising but less solid: dietary fibres have so far only been studied in people who had undergone gastric surgery, and the direct link to GLP-1 in healthy individuals has not yet been established. The claim describes a chain from gut to hormone that the current state of research does not yet fully cover.
Partly
“Whey protein consumed before a meal stimulates the production of the hormone GLP-1 and lowers the peak in blood sugar levels.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Whey protein and partially hydrolysed milk proteins do demonstrably raise GLP-1, but this has only been shown in small studies and the evidence is still limited. The second part of the claim, that this also lowers the blood sugar peak, is not supported by the available research findings; those findings concern GLP-1 stimulation through food, not the direct effect on the blood sugar peak. Presenting both effects as established facts therefore goes beyond what the research currently substantiates.
Partly
“Older adults on a vegetarian diet build less muscle mass during strength training than meat eaters because they consume less protein.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Vegetarians do not, on average, consume less protein than meat eaters, so the cause stated in the claim is incorrect. Plant-based protein is, however, of slightly lower quality and is less well absorbed, which deserves extra attention in older adults since they already need more protein to maintain muscle mass. Moreover, studies on muscle growth during strength training show no demonstrable difference between soy and animal protein over longer periods. The claim identifies a genuine point of concern for older vegetarians, but points to the wrong culprit.
Partly
“The muscle load of interval training activates AMPK and the PGC-1a gene, leading to the creation of additional mitochondria.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Exercise demonstrably activates AMPK in humans, and it is well established that AMPK in turn stimulates the production of new mitochondria in muscles. The role of PGC-1a in that chain is biologically plausible, but the information provided does not explicitly cite this gene as a demonstrated step in human research. Moreover, the evidence concerns exercise in general, or even specifically endurance exercise, and not interval training as the most effective activator of AMPK or mitochondrial biogenesis. The direction of the claim is therefore correct, but the precise route via PGC-1a and the emphasis on interval training go beyond what the research here actually establishes.
Partly
“Strength training reduces hot flushes and improves bone density in menopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The effect of strength training on bone density after the menopause has been demonstrated, but it is limited in size and the quality of the evidence is low to moderate. For hot flushes, there is no evidence that strength training helps: the interventions shown to work are hormone therapy, certain non-hormonal medications and psychological therapy. The claim therefore combines a partially supported assertion with one that has not been demonstrated.
✗ Does not hold up
“A single strength training session increases oestrogen and testosterone concentrations in women of all ages.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that the hormonal response to strength training in women is far from straightforward. A review study reports that findings on testosterone in women after a strength training session are inconsistent: sometimes a rise is observed, sometimes no change at all. Another review confirms this and points out that hormonal fluctuations caused by the menstrual cycle make interpretation difficult. In postmenopausal women, a carefully designed randomised controlled study found that 12 weeks of strength training actually lowered oestradiol and testosterone concentrations in muscle tissue, while a single bout of exercise had no effect on these values. A study in young female runners found no clear change in resting blood hormone levels, including oestradiol and testosterone, after 16 weeks of strength training. The claim that strength training raises both oestrogen and testosterone in women of all ages is therefore not supported and is contradicted on multiple points by research that examined precisely this question.
Partly
“Beta-glucans in oats slow digestion and stimulate GLP-1 production, thereby reducing hunger signals.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is well established that GLP-1 suppresses hunger signals: the hormone slows gastric emptying, influences brain areas that regulate satiety and leads to lower spontaneous food intake. The claim that beta-glucans in oats specifically stimulate GLP-1 production and thereby reduce hunger signals goes further than what the available research shows. There is no evidence in the available literature confirming that oat beta-glucans work via this mechanism in humans. The reasoning is plausible in principle, but the chain from oats to slowed digestion to a rise in GLP-1 to reduced hunger has not been demonstrated as a whole.
Partly
“After the age of forty, most women become more susceptible to insulin resistance, causing blood sugar spikes after a carbohydrate-rich meal to be higher and to drop more slowly.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is correct that women over forty more often develop insulin resistance: research shows that the menopause alters fat storage and hormonal balance in ways that reduce insulin sensitivity. What the claim adds, namely that blood sugar spikes after a carbohydrate-rich meal are specifically higher and drop more slowly, is a logical consequence of insulin resistance, but that precise pattern in women over forty is not so concretely supported in the available studies. The direction of the claim is therefore correct, but the wording goes somewhat further than what the evidence directly shows.
Partly
“Eating carbohydrates when breaking a fast restores active T3 thyroid hormone levels.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that orally administered glucose after a fasting period can normalize reduced T3 levels, but that intravenously administered glucose does not have that effect. This points to a role for the gastrointestinal tract or associated hormones such as insulin. Animal studies and laboratory studies confirm that carbohydrates and insulin together restore T3 production, but also show that the effect of carbohydrates alone, without insulin, is not always found and that the precise mechanism has not yet been fully elucidated. Moreover, a study in rats shows that after prolonged fasting of six days, resuming food intake no longer produces any recovery of T3 at all, which means that the claim is too broad as an absolute rule.
Partly
“Gut bacteria convert substances from berries into nutrients that help lower blood pressure”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Polyphenols from berries have a beneficial effect on gut bacteria, and blueberries measurably improve blood vessel flexibility. The idea that gut bacteria convert polyphenols into substances that subsequently lower blood pressure is a biologically plausible mechanism, but this specific pathway from gut bacteria to a reduction in blood pressure has not been demonstrated in the available studies in humans. The effect on blood pressure itself is described as small, and the research is still too limited to draw firm conclusions about the pathway responsible for it.
Partly
“Sweet potatoes cause a smaller rise in blood sugar than regular potatoes, which means less insulin is released”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans and animals shows that sweet potatoes have a beneficial effect on blood sugar, but the comparison with regular potatoes and the mechanism of reduced insulin release are more nuanced. A study in rats actually shows that sweet potatoes lower blood sugar without raising insulin levels, because insulin sensitivity improves. A study in ten people shows that boiled purple sweet potatoes have a glycaemic index of 63.5, but a direct comparison with regular potatoes in humans is absent from this research. The claim that less insulin is therefore released does not simply hold up: in the rat study, blood sugar falls precisely because insulin works more effectively, not because less insulin is produced.
✗ Does not hold up
“Of all legumes, lentils are the most effective at lowering blood sugar levels after a meal”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that lentils clearly lower blood sugar levels after a meal compared to starchy foods such as bread, rice and potatoes. However, a comparison between lentils and other legumes shows that the glycaemic index of lentils overlaps with that of chickpeas, beans, peas and other legumes, and that lentils do not always have the lowest values. No research identifies lentils as the most effective legume; on the contrary, a comparative review study shows that the GI ranges of the various legumes are strongly determined by preparation method and overlap considerably. The claim therefore goes beyond what the research supports.
Partly
“The menopause increases women's risk of developing type 2 diabetes”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
The menopause brings changes in body composition that can increase the risk of type 2 diabetes: more abdominal fat, less muscle mass and a slower metabolism are well-known risk factors for insulin resistance. It is also well established that the menopause has a direct impact on women's cardiovascular and metabolic profile. However, a direct link between the menopause and an increased risk of type 2 diabetes is not explicitly established in the available research. The direction is plausible, but the claim goes beyond what the evidence conclusively shows.
Partly
“Glycine in bone broth helps to repair the lining of the intestinal wall”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A review study from the Mayo Clinic shows that substances in bone broth, including glycine, may support the intestinal wall, but evidence in humans is still limited. Moreover, the study examines multiple substances at once, not glycine in isolation. Animal research shows that glycine protects the intestinal wall better in irradiated rats than in rats that did not receive the substance. One randomised controlled study in humans found no effect of supplemental glycine on intestinal permeability. The claim that glycine in bone broth specifically repairs the intestinal wall goes beyond what research has so far demonstrated in humans: the evidence comes largely from animal and laboratory studies, and bone broth as a whole has barely been studied in human trials. → Does bone broth help your gut health?
Partly
“The hormone oestrogen protects the body against the development of insulin resistance.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Oestrogen plays a role in insulin sensitivity: when levels drop during menopause, insulin resistance measurably increases, and hormone therapy with oestrogen demonstrably lowers that resistance. However, 'protects against the development' goes further than the research shows: the effect of oestrogen is probably too small to be noticeable in practice in women without diabetes, and a fully protective effect has not been demonstrated.
Partly
“Cinnamon boosts metabolism.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that cinnamon can have a beneficial effect on blood sugar and certain blood fats, particularly in people with type 2 diabetes. These are metabolic effects, but they concern blood sugar regulation and lipid levels, not an increased rate of energy burning, which is what 'boosting metabolism' usually implies. The claim that cinnamon boosts metabolism is supported only by animal research, in which a cinnamon extract increased heat production and energy expenditure in mice exposed to the cold. Whether this effect also occurs in humans has not yet been tested in human studies.
Partly
“Women going through menopause who eat higher-quality carbohydrates experience significantly fewer menopausal symptoms.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Two observational studies in which women were followed without the researchers making any changes to their lifestyle, conducted in postmenopausal women (393 and 604 participants respectively), do find an association between better carbohydrate quality and fewer menopausal symptoms, particularly physical and psychological complaints. A review study summarising multiple studies and a shorter summary study confirm that dietary patterns rich in fibre and wholegrains go together with less severe symptoms. Because all these studies are purely observational, the research cannot tell us whether better carbohydrate quality actually reduces symptoms or whether another explanation is at play. The claim that women experience 'significantly fewer' symptoms therefore goes beyond what these studies can demonstrate. → What helps against menopause symptoms like hot flushes and mood swings?
✗ Does not hold up
“Phytoestrogens from soy speed up metabolism, causing women to burn more calories.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into soy phytoestrogens focuses on effects such as hot flashes, bone loss and hormonal activity, not on an accelerated metabolism or increased calorie burning. Research into what influences metabolism points to muscle mass, physical activity and protein intake as the determining factors, not phytoestrogens. No evidence has been found that soy isoflavones measurably increase energy expenditure in women.
Partly
“Oestrogen converts white fat into brown fat, making it easier for the body to burn fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that oestrogen is indeed involved in the formation of beige fat cells in white adipose tissue and in the activity of brown fat, which can promote fat burning through heat production. This is evident from several review studies and animal research. However, an important detail is missing from the claim: oestrogen exerts this effect largely through the brain (the hypothalamus), and not solely through a direct action on fat cells themselves. Moreover, in white fat it is strictly speaking a conversion to beige fat, not brown fat, and whether this works the same way in humans as in animals has not yet been fully established.
Partly
“Oestrogen increases the basal metabolic rate, causing the body to burn more energy throughout the day.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research does indeed show that oestrogen plays a role in energy balance and energy expenditure: in women, a decline in oestrogen around the menopause is associated with a lower metabolic rate, increased fat storage and weight gain. Mouse studies show that oestradiol promotes energy expenditure. The claim is therefore correct in its direction, but the precise assertion that oestrogen raises the basal metabolic rate is an oversimplification: research in humans actually indicates that resting energy expenditure is generally higher in men than in women, and that oestrogen primarily regulates energy balance through several mechanisms simultaneously, such as appetite regulation and fat distribution. Direct evidence that oestrogen raises the basal metabolic rate in humans has not yet been demonstrated in the studies described.
✗ Does not hold up
“Eating half to one cup of sauerkraut daily for four weeks increases the amount of short-chain fatty acids in the blood.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A study in 87 people examined exactly this: eating sauerkraut daily for four weeks and the effect on short-chain fatty acids in the blood. Only in the group that ate pasteurised sauerkraut did those fatty acids increase. That effect was not found with fresh sauerkraut. The claim assumes that sauerkraut in general has this effect, but the research shows that the type of sauerkraut matters. The other two studies concern fermentation processes and a different substance found in sauerkraut, and say nothing about short-chain fatty acids in the blood in humans.
Partly
“Eating bitter foods stimulates bitter taste receptors in the gut, causing the hormone GLP-1 to be released.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That food can stimulate GLP-1 is well-supported, but the available studies point primarily to tryptophan-rich protein sources and partially hydrolysed milk proteins, not specifically to bitter foods. The role of bitter taste receptors in the gut in GLP-1 release is not addressed in the available research, meaning that mechanism cannot be substantiated. The general direction of the claim, that nutrients trigger GLP-1 release via gut receptors, is consistent with how this hormone works in general, but the specific claim about bitter receptors goes beyond what the evidence supports.
Partly
“Konjac noodles slow the absorption of nutrients in the intestines, leading to a longer-lasting feeling of satiety.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that the active fibre in konjac noodles primarily slows gastric emptying and thereby produces a longer-lasting feeling of satiety. One carefully designed randomised controlled study, conducted in 22 healthy adults, confirms that a higher viscosity of this fibre leads to a significantly greater feeling of satiety. The claim is therefore correct regarding the mechanism of action and the satiety effect, but the mechanism described specifically concerns delayed gastric emptying due to the viscosity of the fibre, rather than primarily a slowing of nutrient absorption in the intestines. That is a related but distinct mechanism, and for that specific part of the claim there is less direct evidence from human studies.
Partly
“Bifidobacterium adolescentis inhibits fat absorption in the body and reduces intestinal inflammation.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Studies in mice show that certain strains of Bifidobacterium adolescentis can reduce intestinal inflammation and contribute to less fat accumulation, but the effects on fat absorption and inflammation are highly strain-specific: not every strain works the same way, and one strain even caused weight gain in mice. The evidence on intestinal inflammation comes from animal and laboratory studies; in humans, the effect has not yet been demonstrated in clinical trials, even though some studies show that bacterial levels are reduced in people with intestinal inflammation. The claim suggests a broad and established effect in humans, while the research is still largely at an early stage.
Partly
“An interval protocol of 4 minutes of intense exercise and 3 minutes of rest (4 repetitions) improves VO2 peak more than continuous cardio training.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Long-interval training does indeed improve VO2 peak more than continuous cardio at moderate intensity, and this is well supported. However, the research points to blocks of at least 2 minutes at high intensity as the effective basis, not to one specific protocol of 4 minutes of exercise and 3 minutes of rest. The claim is therefore correct in its direction, but presenting this one protocol as the best cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available evidence.
Partly
“Adults with persistently high cortisol levels have a 72 percent greater chance of obesity”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is well established that chronically high cortisol is associated with more abdominal fat and a disrupted metabolism: in people with structurally elevated cortisol levels, deep abdominal fat demonstrably accumulates and the risk of insulin resistance increases. However, that precise percentage of 72 percent greater chance of obesity cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research. The direction of the claim is correct, but the specific figure creates a false sense of precision that the evidence does not support.
Partly
“Fragmented sleep leads to 27 percent higher cortisol levels in women the following morning”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A study of 22 healthy young women shows that fragmented sleep raised cortisol levels at the end of the day by 27 percent compared to uninterrupted sleep. That figure is therefore exactly right. However, it refers to cortisol levels in the evening before going to sleep, not to levels the following morning. The claim says "the following morning", while that same study actually shows that the cortisol response after waking from fragmented sleep clearly declined. The other studies look at sleep deprivation, sleep quality or disruptions to the circadian rhythm in mixed groups, and do not connect to this specific figure.
Partly
“Adults around the age of 48 with the highest cortisol levels have a smaller brain volume.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in adults does indeed show that higher cortisol levels are associated with smaller brain volume, particularly in the cerebral cortex and the hippocampus. Studies in people with an average age of 59 and in those aged 65 and over found that higher cortisol goes hand in hand with greater shrinkage in those brain regions, and in patients with a condition in which cortisol is chronically and severely elevated, researchers observe a clear reduction in hippocampal volume. The claim is therefore correct in its direction, but specifies the age of "around 48", whereas the available research in humans involves other age groups, predominantly those aged 59 and over and those aged 65 and over. This specific age group has not yet been examined in this research.
Partly
“Strength training significantly lowers HbA1c levels, with greater gains in muscle strength going hand in hand with a greater reduction in blood sugar.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That strength training lowers blood sugar is supported by research: there are multiple indications that it improves insulin sensitivity, and in people with type 2 diabetes and a normal weight it even appears to work better than cardio alone. However, the claim goes a step further by asserting that greater gains in muscle strength are associated with a greater reduction in blood sugar; that specific relationship cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available evidence. Moreover, the blood sugar benefit is not unconditional: in people with excess weight, diet plays a greater role than type of exercise, and the evidence is still limited to a small number of studies.
Partly
“Taking psyllium fibre before meals reduces fat around the organs and improves HbA1c.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Taking psyllium before meals demonstrably improves blood sugar regulation in people with type 2 diabetes: the post-meal spike decreases, and with longer use, so do fasting blood sugar and HbA1c. That part of the claim is correct. The claim about fat around the organs goes beyond the evidence: research shows that soluble fibre can modestly reduce body weight and body fat percentage, but whether psyllium specifically targets visceral fat has not been demonstrated, and registered trials testing this in humans are currently lacking.
✓ Holds up
“Adults who habitually sleep fewer than six hours a night have an 8% higher chance of developing abdominal fat than people who sleep enough.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A large-scale study pooling the results of seven long-running population studies in adults shows that short sleep is associated with an 8% higher chance of abdominal fat, which is exactly the figure mentioned in the claim. Several other studies in adults confirm the link between short sleep and greater abdominal fat, measured in various ways. The claim specifies 'fewer than six hours', whereas the threshold in the pooled study is not clearly specified and other studies sometimes use a different threshold; however, the 8% figure cited comes directly from that study.
Partly
“Eating within a daily window of 8 to 10 hours improves HbA1c in adults with metabolic syndrome.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Intermittent fasting probably improves insulin resistance and fasting blood sugar, and eating early in the day appears to have the strongest support within that framework. However, the available studies are predominantly small and short-term, and a specific effect on HbA1c in people with metabolic syndrome cannot be firmly established based on current research. The claim therefore points in a plausible direction, but is formulated too precisely for what the evidence allows.
Partly
“Creatine draws water into the muscles; when the muscles are not trained, this leads to a bloated feeling and fluid retention.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is true that creatine draws water into the muscles: it increases the fluid content of muscle tissue, which in some people temporarily leads to weight gain. However, the second part of the claim goes further than the research shows. Studies in non-exercising adults actually show positive effects on muscle mass and strength, without fluid retention or a bloated feeling being reported as a side effect. It has not been demonstrated that a lack of training turns creatine's water-binding effect into an uncomfortable bloated feeling.
Partly
“Combining creatine with resistance training leads to fat loss and an increase in lean muscle mass, regardless of age or sex.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The combination of creatine and resistance training does indeed lead to a modest improvement in body composition: a slight increase in lean muscle mass and a small effect on fat mass. However, the claim goes too far by describing this as fat loss and suggesting that the effect is equally strong regardless of age or sex. The available research shows that the effects vary and that the evidence for specific groups remains limited, especially when it comes to the direct effect on fat loss. Total body weight also often increases slightly due to additional muscle mass and water retention, which clouds the picture of fat loss.
Partly
“A drop in glucose and insulin during fasting stimulates the kidneys to excrete sodium.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
Research in obese people who fasted does indeed show that falling insulin levels play a key role in the excretion of sodium by the kidneys during fasting. One study concludes specifically that reduced insulin secretion is the main hormonal factor behind natriuresis during fasting, because insulin normally stimulates sodium reabsorption in the kidneys. However, the role of glucose is less straightforward: a more recent hypothesis proposes that reduced glucose transport in the kidneys contributes to sodium excretion, but this has not yet been confirmed experimentally and is considered speculative. The claim is therefore correct with regard to insulin, but oversimplifies the picture for glucose and also fails to mention that glucagon and ketones may contribute to the process.
Partly
“Symptoms such as keto flu, fatigue during fasting, and heart palpitations are often caused by a sodium deficiency.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
There is some research on sodium and fatigue during fasting, but it is limited to sodium bicarbonate in trained men during intense exercise. Whether a sodium deficiency causes everyday fasting fatigue, keto flu, or heart palpitations has not been studied. The claim presents a sodium deficiency as a common and well-established cause of all these complaints, but that goes beyond what the available research shows.
Too early
“Sodium intake calms the adrenal glands and helps the body out of a fight-or-flight state.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
One mouse study shows that chronically consuming extra salt dampens the stress response via the adrenal axis: in mice on a high-salt diet, stress hormone production following a stressful event was lower than in control animals. That is an interesting indication, but it involves animal research. Research in humans focuses on precisely the opposite: higher salt intake raises blood pressure partly by making the nervous system that controls heart rate and blood vessels more active. It has not yet been demonstrated in humans that sodium intake "calms" the adrenal glands or helps the body out of a fight-or-flight state.
Partly
“Continuous aerobic exercise such as walking lowers cortisol levels.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that regular exercise can lower cortisol levels, but the effect depends strongly on intensity. One study with men shows that low intensity (comparable to a gentle walk) does not noticeably raise cortisol and, when other factors are taken into account, even lowers it slightly, whereas moderate to high intensity actually causes cortisol to rise during exertion. Large studies combining the results of multiple trials in adults and older adults confirm a beneficial long-term effect of regular exercise on cortisol, but one review concludes that there is no clear consensus on the effect of exercise on cortisol in older adults. The claim is therefore broadly correct for regular exercise, but too categorical because it makes no distinction between the immediate response during physical activity and the long-term effect, and because it disregards intensity.
Partly
“Sardines contain hardly any mercury because they are low in the marine food chain.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Multiple studies confirm that sardines do indeed have low mercury levels and generally remain well below the European safety limit. The first part of the claim is therefore correct. However, the explanation that this is simply because sardines are low in the food chain is an oversimplification. Research shows that the amount of mercury in fish depends strongly on how much mercury is already absorbed at the base of the food chain, and that this varies considerably between ecosystems. Moreover, a Mediterranean study found that species at higher levels of the food chain can also sometimes have low mercury levels, which means that position in the food chain is not the only explanation for the low mercury content of sardines.
Partly
“Phytoestrogens in soy raise oestrogen levels and reduce menopausal symptoms.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Phytoestrogens do not raise blood oestrogen levels: randomised trials show no measurable hormonal effect at normal dietary intake. The claim that they reduce menopausal symptoms is partly correct: soy isoflavones can modestly reduce hot flushes, but the effect is small and studies are conflicting. No demonstrable effect has been found on night sweats or broader menopausal symptoms, and the underlying mechanism therefore differs fundamentally from what the claim suggests.
Partly
“Five minutes of cyclic sighing daily lowers breathing rate and improves mood more effectively than mindfulness meditation.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
One study in people (Stanford, published in 2023) does show that five minutes of daily cyclic sighing lowers breathing rate and improves mood more than mindfulness meditation, and those differences were large enough to be meaningful. The claim is therefore correct in terms of direction and population. However, it goes slightly further than the evidence warrants: it is based on a single study, the effects were measured over one month, and the second study mentioned in the abstracts concerns a different breathing technique (GRMT) in nurses and does not directly support the claim. On the basis of one study, it is too early to present "more effective than mindfulness meditation" as an established fact.
Partly
“Protein increases energy expenditure and metabolism more than carbohydrates and fats because it is the hardest for the body to digest.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans does indeed show that protein has a higher thermogenic response (additional energy expenditure after a meal) than fat, and that a high-protein diet increases energy expenditure and metabolism more than a low-protein diet. The direction of the claim is therefore correct. However, the reason given is not entirely accurate: the higher thermogenesis of protein is not simply due to difficult digestion, but to the energy costs of processing and building proteins in the body. Moreover, a review study indicates that carbohydrates can have a thermogenic effect comparable to that of fat, and that it is fat that produces the lowest thermogenic response, not carbohydrates.
Partly
“MCT oil suppresses appetite better than coconut oil or vegetable oil.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
One study directly compared MCT oil with coconut oil and vegetable oil in humans and found that MCT oil caused people to eat less at a subsequent meal and to feel fuller than with the other two oils. A large-scale analysis summarising and analysing the results of seventeen separate studies confirms that MCT can reduce total food intake compared with ordinary long-chain fats, but a clear effect on the feeling of hunger or satiety itself was not found. In addition, two separate human studies showed no effect of MCT on appetite or food intake compared with vegetable oil, which indicates that the results are mixed. The claim therefore broadly points in the right direction for coconut oil, but the evidence is not clear-cut enough to state that MCT oil suppresses appetite better in all circumstances.
Partly
“Seated calf raises reduce the blood sugar spike after a meal by about half.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that seated calf raises (soleus push-ups) do substantially lower the blood sugar spike after a meal, but the percentages found vary: a pilot study with people with prediabetes found a reduction of about 32%, and a review study cites a range of 39 to 52%. The claim that the spike drops "by about half" is therefore accurate for the upper end of that range, but is too categorical as a general statement. Moreover, the pilot study involved only ten participants, and the review authors emphasise that more long-term research is needed. Other studies in this review examined different exercises or different outcomes, such as insulin response or blood flow, and did not directly test the "half" claim. → Does a walk after eating help control your blood sugar?
Partly
“Cortisol suppresses calorie-burning brown fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that the relationship between cortisol and brown fat is more complex than the claim suggests. A review study concludes that glucocorticoids probably do not truly suppress brown fat: what looks like a decrease often turns out to be a so-called dilution effect, and only at very low levels of brown fat activity is there possibly some limited real inhibition. The only study conducted in humans even found the opposite: an infusion of hydrocortisone raised the temperature of brown fat in healthy men. Studies in mice and sheep do show that exposure to high doses of glucocorticoids before birth can impair the development and functioning of brown fat in offspring, but that concerns prenatal exposure, not the effect of cortisol in adults. The claim that cortisol suppresses brown fat is therefore not straightforwardly correct and overlooks the contradictory findings in humans.
✓ Holds up
“Fasting for 36 hours on water alone changes 245 out of 832 lipid markers in the blood.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A controlled pilot study with 20 healthy adults shows exactly this: after fasting for 36 hours on water alone, 245 of the 832 lipid species examined in the blood had changed significantly compared to the baseline values. The claim therefore corresponds exactly to what is reported in that study. Since it concerns a small pilot study in young, healthy participants, the researchers themselves emphasise that confirmation in larger groups is needed, but the claim as a factual finding is correct.
Partly
“Taking in 2.5 to 3 grams of leucine through a meal stimulates muscle growth.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research supports the idea that leucine plays a key role in triggering muscle growth: sources with a high leucine content, such as whey protein, stimulate muscle protein synthesis per meal more strongly than protein sources with less leucine. However, the threshold of 2.5 to 3 grams of leucine per meal does not appear in the available research, and that specific cut-off cannot be substantiated. The direction of the claim is correct, but presenting the precise number of grams as a fixed threshold goes beyond what the evidence allows.
✗ Does not hold up
“According to a meta-analysis, alternate-day fasting leads to greater weight loss than continuous caloric restriction.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several systematic reviews pooling the results of earlier randomised studies show that alternate-day fasting and daily caloric restriction lead to comparable weight loss. One such review ranks alternate-day fasting highest among fasting variants, but finds no difference compared with daily caloric restriction large enough to draw conclusions from. Another review even finds that daily caloric restriction produces slightly greater weight loss than alternate-day fasting, but that difference is also too small to be meaningful. The claim that alternate-day fasting leads to greater weight loss is therefore not supported by the research. → Does a fasting-mimicking diet work better than simply eating less?
✗ Does not hold up
“Green leafy vegetables contain the short-chain fatty acid butyrate, which stimulates the production of the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The claim contains two problems. First, butyrate is not found directly in green leafy vegetables: it is a short-chain fatty acid produced by gut bacteria when they break down dietary fibre, not a substance you take in through the vegetables themselves. Second, research into nutrition and GLP-1 shows that the strongest evidence points to tryptophan-rich proteins and partially broken-down milk proteins, not to butyrate or leafy vegetables. No evidence has been found that butyrate from green vegetables stimulates GLP-1 production in humans.
Partly
“Grass-fed beef contains about five times as many omega-3 fatty acids as grain-fed beef.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several studies confirm that grass-fed beef contains significantly more omega-3 fatty acids than grain-fed beef, but the exact difference varies considerably. One large study of more than 300 commercial beef samples from North America, for instance, shows that the ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acids is on average nearly four times more favourable in grass-fed meat, while also revealing enormous variation: some grass-fed samples had omega-3 levels comparable to those of grain-fed meat. Other review studies describe the omega-3 content of grass-fed beef as "clearly higher", but do not cite a fixed multiplication factor of five. The factor of five is therefore not supported by the available research; the studies show that the advantage is real, but highly dependent on breed, feeding practice, and which type of omega-3 is being measured.
Partly
“Using olive oil daily lowers the inflammatory markers C-reactive protein and interleukin-6 in the blood.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Olive oil appears to be more beneficial than butter with regard to the temporary rise in IL-6 after a high-fat meal, but that is not the same as a proven reduction in CRP or IL-6 with daily use. Research into high-fat meals actually shows that CRP barely responds to what you eat, and the effect on IL-6 is an acute peak that olive oil may dampen, not a structurally lower level resulting from daily use. The claim suggests a broad and consistent effect on two specific inflammatory markers, and that goes beyond what the available evidence supports.
Partly
“Kimchi can bind to plastics and helps the body to eliminate them.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that lactic acid bacteria, such as those found in kimchi, can bind to plastic particles in the lab and in mice and excrete them via the stool. One study comes specifically from the World Institute of Kimchi and demonstrates that a kimchi bacterium efficiently absorbs nanoplastics and increases their excretion via the stool, but this was studied in animals, not in humans. The claim that kimchi itself, as a product, does this in humans goes beyond what research has shown so far: studies focus on specific bacterial strains under controlled conditions, not on kimchi as a food that people eat.
✗ Does not hold up
“The hunger hormone ghrelin peaks around 24 hours of fasting and then switches off the feeling of hunger.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans does not show that ghrelin peaks around 24 hours of fasting and then "switches off" the feeling of hunger. A study in healthy women who fasted completely for four days actually shows that ghrelin levels fell during fasting, even though growth hormone rose. Another study in healthy men found no increase in ghrelin at all after two days of energy restriction, and ghrelin levels did not predict subsequent food intake either. It is well established that ghrelin peaks before each meal and drops afterwards, but that pattern is linked to meal timing rather than to a specific point of 24 hours of fasting, and research provides no evidence of hunger being "switched off" after such a peak.
✗ Does not hold up
“Resistant starch in cooked and then cooled potatoes increases GLP-1 production and reduces hunger.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that cooled potatoes (which contain more resistant starch) have no measurable effect on GLP-1, and do not reduce perceived hunger or satiety either. One study in women with elevated blood sugar levels did find lower glucose and insulin levels after eating cooled potatoes, but no difference in GLP-1 or satiety. A study in pigs even found lower GLP-1 levels with resistant starch. Studies on resistant starch as a supplement or from sources other than potatoes (maize, wheat) likewise found no effect on GLP-1 or hunger in humans. The claim is therefore not supported by this research: neither the increase in GLP-1 nor the reduction in hunger has been demonstrated for cooled potatoes.
Partly
“Oat fibre (beta-glucan) forms a gel that slows gastric emptying and reduces hunger.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The slowing of gastric emptying by beta-glucan is well supported by human research: a carefully designed randomised study showed that beta-glucan-rich oat bread significantly slowed gastric emptying in healthy adults, and another study confirmed this for oat beta-glucan based on the viscosity of the substance. The effect on hunger and food intake, however, is far less clear: multiple systematic reviews of such human studies show that the effects on satiety and actual food consumption are inconsistent and often so small as to be barely measurable, and one study even found no effect on appetite or food intake despite slowed gastric emptying. The claim that gel formation reduces hunger therefore goes beyond what research has firmly established so far.
Partly
“Sleep deprivation increases the release of ghrelin and lowers leptin, leading to greater appetite and food cravings.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several human studies do indeed show that sleep deprivation raises ghrelin, lowers leptin and increases appetite. A large study involving more than a thousand adults and a randomised study confirm this pattern. A meta-analysis combining and comparing the results of dozens of experiments also supports the link between short sleep and higher ghrelin levels. Nevertheless, the picture is not clear-cut: another review of such studies found no clearly measurable effect of sleep deprivation on leptin and ghrelin, and an experiment involving severe sleep deprivation (just two hours per night) even showed a decrease in appetite and energy intake, without any hormonal changes. The claim therefore holds for moderate sleep deprivation in some of the groups studied, but does not apply in all cases or to everyone.
Partly
“Stress depletes the body's magnesium stores, and low magnesium levels make you more susceptible to stress.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The second part of the claim, that low magnesium levels make you more susceptible to stress, is supported by research: there is a visible link between low magnesium status and greater sensitivity to anxiety and stress, and supplements helped in some of the groups studied. The first part, that stress depletes magnesium stores, does not appear in the available research and therefore cannot be substantiated. The claim presents both directions as established facts, while the evidence for half of it is lacking.
Partly
“Taking 500 mg of ashwagandha before bedtime helps people fall asleep faster and improves sleep quality.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Ashwagandha is indeed often taken in the evening in the hope of improving sleep, but whether the timing matters has never been studied. The dose of 500 mg falls within the range of 300–600 mg used in research on stress and anxiety, but those studies do not specifically address sleep quality or time to fall asleep. Moreover, the Dutch National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM) warns of possible liver, thyroid and hormonal damage from ashwagandha, which cannot be ignored when recommending it for daily use before bedtime. For those who genuinely struggle with sleep problems, cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia is a much better-supported approach.
Partly
“Taking kava before bedtime reduces sleep disturbances and improves deep sleep and overall sleep quality.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that kava can noticeably improve sleep and stress symptoms in people with stress-related sleep problems, but this is based on a single small exploratory study without a control group and with only 24 participants. Animal research in rats shows that kava shortens the time it takes to fall asleep and increases delta activity during deep sleep, which may indicate better sleep quality. However, broader review studies conclude that the evidence for herbal sleep aids in humans is limited and inconsistent, and that more well-designed research is needed. The claim therefore goes beyond what current research in humans can firmly support, and the findings from animal research have not yet been confirmed in humans.
Partly
“Spreading protein intake across 4 to 5 meals per day is the key to maximum satiety.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research supports spreading protein intake across multiple meals for muscle building, with four meals of around 0.4 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight serving as a practical guideline. However, the claim is specifically about satiety, and the available findings do not address that: what has been studied is muscle protein synthesis, not appetite suppression. The link between protein distribution and maximum satiety therefore cannot be established on the basis of what the research currently shows.
Partly
“A loading phase with a higher dose of creatine can cause the body to temporarily retain fluid.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
That creatine causes fluid retention is correct: total body weight increases slightly due to extra muscle mass and fluid, and this is confirmed by the available research. The claim adds the word 'temporarily', but the evidence does not clearly show that this fluid effect is specifically temporary or limited to the loading phase; fluid retention also plays a role with regular use. The general direction of the claim is correct, but the specification that it concerns a temporary effect of the loading phase cannot be firmly established based on the available research.
✗ Does not hold up
“The body needs at least 5 grams of creatine per day.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The research cites 3 to 5 grams of creatine per day as the best-supported dose for muscle strength and explosive performance, not a minimum of 5 grams. A minimum of 5 grams per day is therefore not supported: a clear effect is already seen at 3 grams. The claim sets a lower limit that is higher than what the evidence shows.
Partly
“Eating protein every few hours is an effective way to reduce belly fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that a high-protein diet is associated with less belly fat, but the role of eating frequency in itself is far less clear. One study in overweight adults found that six high-protein meals a day reduced belly fat more than three meals, but total protein intake was also higher in that condition. A position statement by sports scientists argues that daily meal frequency in itself does not play a decisive role in fat reduction, and that total daily protein intake is what matters most. Moreover, one study in healthy men found that more eating occasions per day on a high-calorie diet actually increased belly fat, showing that eating frequency can also have a negative effect depending on the context.
✗ Does not hold up
“After three to four weeks of creatine use combined with strength training, sleep and concentration improve.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with caution
The claim combines two assertions that the research does not firmly support in the way they are presented. Regarding sleep, small studies show slightly more positive subjective sleep experiences, but objective sleep measurements show no effect. Regarding concentration and memory, the evidence is strongest in older adults, vegetarians, or people under mental stress; in young, healthy people who sleep normally, the effect is small to negligible. A time window of three to four weeks combined with strength training is nowhere identified as the determining factor for these two outcomes, and presenting both as an expected result clearly goes beyond what the research shows.
Partly
“It takes four weeks of daily intake before creatine levels in the body are fully saturated.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A loading phase of five to seven days at a higher dose can bring creatine levels in the muscles up to speed quickly, after which you switch to a maintenance dose of three to five grams per day. Four weeks of daily intake without a loading phase works too, but the claim that this is the only or standard timeline goes beyond what the research states. Moreover, the threshold of being "fully saturated" after exactly four weeks cannot be firmly established based on the available evidence.
✗ Does not hold up
“Using stevia daily for two weeks changes the composition of gut bacteria in a negative way”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several studies in humans, including a carefully designed four-week randomised study and a twelve-week study, find no clear changes in the composition of gut bacteria from daily stevia use. A review article even concludes that stevia may be beneficial for the diversity of gut bacteria. One study in rats did find changes in the gut flora, but results in animals are no proof of what happens in humans. The claim that two weeks of daily stevia use changes gut bacteria in a negative way is not supported by the available research in humans and is even at odds with the findings of those human studies.
Partly
“Erythritol is associated with an increased risk of heart attack and stroke”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several large observational studies, in which participants are followed without researchers intervening, show that higher levels of erythritol in the blood are associated with an increased risk of serious cardiovascular problems, including heart attack and stroke. A study in which healthy volunteers were given erythritol also shows that consuming erythritol makes platelets more active, which can promote clotting. There is, however, an important caveat: those first-mentioned studies measure erythritol in the blood, but a large proportion of it is produced by the body itself as a sign of a disrupted sugar metabolism. It has therefore not yet been proven that erythritol as a sweetener in food is the cause of the risks identified. Long-term studies into the effects of erythritol as a dietary ingredient on cardiovascular disease are still lacking.
Partly
“Large amounts of allulose can cause bloating and loose stools”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in healthy adults shows that allulose can indeed cause gastrointestinal complaints at higher doses, including diarrhoea and bloating (abdominal distension). The claim is therefore broadly correct. However, it goes slightly beyond what the evidence supports: these complaints only occur at quite high single doses, and with regular intake in large amounts other complaints also occurred, such as nausea and abdominal pain. "Loose stools" as a separate complaint is not mentioned as such; diarrhoea is. The claim also suggests that this happens to everyone who consumes large amounts, whereas the research shows that the threshold depends on body weight and the manner of intake.
Partly
“Psyllium fibres turn into a gel in the stomach that slows down digestion and suppresses appetite.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Psyllium fibres do indeed form a gel, and this slows the absorption of nutrients, which dampens the rise in blood sugar after a meal. This effect has been most firmly demonstrated in people with type 2 diabetes. The claim that psyllium therefore also suppresses appetite goes beyond what the research shows: that specific effect on appetite is not well established.
Partly
“Eating lentils stimulates the production of the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Diet can influence GLP-1, but lentils are not specifically identified in the research as a stimulating food source. The strongest evidence points to tryptophan-rich protein sources such as dairy and chicken, and partially hydrolysed milk proteins. Dietary fibre, of which lentils are a rich source, has also been studied, but so far only in people who have undergone gastric surgery, which makes it uncertain whether the findings translate to the general population. The claim about lentils in particular therefore cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research.
Too early
“Compounds in cloves stimulate the production of BDNF (brain-derived neurotrophic factor) in the brain.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
Research in mice and rats shows that compounds from cloves, such as the essential oil and allylguaiacol, can increase BDNF levels in the brain. Studies found, for example, that the essential oil of cloves increased BDNF production in the hippocampus of mice under chronic stress, and that allylguaiacol stimulated BDNF production both in brain cell research and in mice. However, no research has yet been conducted in humans, which means it cannot be said that this effect also occurs in humans.
✗ Does not hold up
“Women respond more strongly to cortisol than men”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans actually shows the opposite: in many situations, men respond more strongly to cortisol than women. A large-scale analysis of 34 studies shows that men have higher cortisol peaks after a stress test than women. A study in people with opioid addiction confirms that men show a stronger cortisol response, while women report more subjective stress. A review study in people with depression finds that depressed women even have a lower cortisol response to stress than depressed men. One study does show that in women a particular hereditary trait influences the cortisol response, but this applies only to a specific subgroup and not to women in general.
Partly
“Yoga exercises such as sun salutations lower cortisol levels”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
A large study that combined the results of 44 separate studies shows that yoga, of all the forms of exercise examined, is most strongly associated with a reduction in cortisol, particularly in people experiencing psychological stress. Broader review studies on relaxation and exercise methods in humans also confirm that cortisol levels drop. The claim is therefore broadly correct. However, the supporting evidence applies to yoga in general, not specifically to sun salutations: studies focusing on that one exercise form in isolation were not included here. Moreover, one carefully designed study in depressed patients who practised Hatha yoga alongside their medication found no additional effect of yoga on cortisol beyond that of the medication, which indicates that the effect does not occur in every situation.
Partly
“Eating less can actually raise cortisol levels in the body”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with caution
Research shows that eating too little can disrupt hormonal balance, but the studies cited in this context primarily mention reproductive hormones and sleep hormones, not cortisol specifically. The idea that eating too little raises cortisol levels is plausible, since the body experiences a significant calorie deficit as a stressor, but that specific claim cannot be firmly established on the basis of the available research. The statement therefore goes beyond what the evidence concretely supports.
Partly
“Chronically elevated cortisol lowers leptin and raises ghrelin, thereby increasing hunger.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that prolonged stress disrupts hormonal balance, with leptin (the satiety hormone) falling and ghrelin (the hunger hormone) rising, leading to increased hunger. This is described in a review article on stress in children and adolescents. At the same time, another carefully conducted analysis of medical studies found that cortisol, leptin, and ghrelin levels did not change noticeably as a result of sleep deprivation, suggesting that the relationship is not always straightforward. Moreover, the available research focuses mainly on stress in general or in specific groups, and the direct causal link between chronically elevated cortisol and the described hormonal changes in humans has not yet been convincingly demonstrated in controlled studies.
✗ Does not hold up
“Dietary fibre stimulates GLP-1 production more effectively in women, whereas intensive exercise stimulates it more strongly in men.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
The claim states that dietary fibre stimulates GLP-1 production more effectively in women and that intensive exercise does so more strongly in men. However, the research shows the opposite for exercise: GLP-1 rose after both moderate and intensive exertion only in women, not in men. Habitual physical activity was indeed linked to a greater GLP-1 response to glucose in men, but this concerns everyday movement habits, not intensive training sessions. The relationship between dietary fibre and sex differences in GLP-1 is not examined in these studies at all, and the direction of the exercise effect is precisely the opposite of what the claim asserts.
✗ Does not hold up
“Highly processed food increases hunger for up to three to four days after consumption by suppressing GLP-1 production”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
The claim contains two specific assertions: that highly processed food increases hunger for up to three to four days after consumption, and that this occurs because the production of GLP-1, a hormone that regulates satiety, is shut down. Research in humans tests both assertions and finds no evidence for them. A carefully designed study in which 32 people were randomly assigned to two groups shows that after fourteen days on a diet rich in highly processed products, the GLP-1 response to a meal was no different from what it had been at the start of the study. The daily hunger score measured early in the morning also remained stable throughout each diet. The assertion that the effect persists for three to four days is not supported anywhere. A review study does note that GLP-1 could theoretically be affected, but concludes that the findings to date are inconsistent. The claim as formulated therefore goes beyond what research in humans shows, and is flatly contradicted by a targeted study as regards both the lasting duration and the suppression of GLP-1. → How bad is ultra-processed food, and what does it do to you?
Partly
“Beans and lentils slow gastric emptying and increase the feeling of satiety”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that legumes such as beans and lentils can increase the feeling of satiety after a meal, particularly in short-term studies lasting a day or less. The delayed gastric emptying effect is attributed in the studies to the soluble fibre in legumes, which forms a gel in the gastrointestinal tract that slows transit, but this mechanism is not tested specifically for beans and lentils individually. Moreover, the studies describe this effect mainly in the context of energy-controlled meals or combination products containing multiple ingredients, and the long-term effects on satiety have not yet been sufficiently studied. The claim is therefore broadly correct, but is worded more broadly than what the available research can support with certainty.
Partly
“Combining fibre with protein and fat slows digestion and prolongs the feeling of satiety”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That fibre slows the rise in blood sugar after a meal has been demonstrated in humans on multiple occasions, and the overall composition of a meal plays a role in this. However, the claim goes further: it states that combining fibre with both protein and fat slows digestion and prolongs the feeling of satiety. The available research provides no direct support for this. What is clear is that the order and composition of a meal affect the blood sugar response, but that is not the same as a demonstrated prolonged feeling of satiety resulting from that specific combination.
✗ Does not hold up
“Probiotic yogurt prevents the hunger hormone ghrelin from rising during a calorie-restricted diet.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A carefully designed randomised study conducted in men with obesity shows that ghrelin actually rises during a calorie-restricted diet, and that taking probiotics made no difference: both groups (probiotics and placebo) showed the same increase in ghrelin. A second study in adults with obesity who combined probiotic yogurt with a calorie-restricted diet did measure ghrelin, but found no clear effect on ghrelin. In addition, a laboratory study using stomach cells shows that a specific probiotic yogurt strain can actually increase ghrelin production. The claim that probiotic yogurt prevents ghrelin from rising during a calorie-restricted diet is therefore not supported by the research and is directly contradicted by one study.
✓ Holds up
“Eating protein alone, without strength training, does not lead to muscle growth in people over fifty.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
Research consistently shows that strength training is a necessary condition for muscle growth, even when protein intake is adequate. Protein alone helps to preserve muscle mass, but a clear anabolic effect has only been demonstrated in combination with training. This applies with particular force to people over fifty, who already have more difficulty responding to protein stimuli due to a reduced sensitivity to protein. The claim is therefore consistent with what the research shows.
Partly
“Eating seaweed increases iodine intake and thereby supports the thyroid gland.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Seaweed does indeed contain iodine, and iodine is essential for a properly functioning thyroid gland. That connection is well established. However, the claim is missing an important side: both too little and too much iodine can disrupt the thyroid gland, and seaweed can contain highly variable amounts of iodine per serving. For people with an existing thyroid condition, eating seaweed regularly can actually throw the gland out of balance. The phrase "thereby supports the thyroid gland" is therefore formulated too unconditionally.
✗ Does not hold up
“After a period of fasting, the amount of the active thyroid hormone T3 doubles as soon as food is eaten again.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that T3 declines during fasting, but that resuming eating does not double this level. In one study of healthy men, T3 did not change measurably after eating was resumed, compared to its level during fasting. Another study of people on caloric restriction actually shows a decline in T3, with no mention of a doubling upon resumption of eating. Research in rats and chickens does show T3 recovering to pre-fasting levels, but no doubling is reported there either.
✗ Does not hold up
“Fasting for 16 hours a day raises thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) in people with an underactive thyroid.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Studies in people with an underactive thyroid show no rise in thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) as a result of fasting. A study in people with a mildly underperforming thyroid compared alternate-day fasting with daily caloric restriction and found no change in TSH or thyroid hormone after six months. A study on 16/8 fasting in healthy, trained men likewise found no clear change in TSH. A well-designed study in thyroid patients who fasted during Ramadan showed that TSH remained stable. A study in people with a disrupted metabolism also found no noticeable change in TSH in the group that ate only within a limited time window. The claim that 16 hours of fasting raises TSH in people with an underactive thyroid is not supported by any available human research; the opposite appears to be more likely the case.
Partly
“Minerals such as iodine, selenium, iron, copper, zinc, calcium and magnesium are essential for thyroid function, and a deficiency in these can cause thyroid disorders.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
It is well established for iodine that both a deficiency and an excess can disrupt the thyroid and cause disorders. For the other minerals mentioned, such as selenium, iron, copper, zinc, calcium and magnesium, the available research does not directly support the role the claim attributes to them in thyroid disorders. The direction of the claim is plausible for iodine, but the broad enumeration of all these minerals as equally proven causes of thyroid disorders goes beyond what the research shows.
✗ Does not hold up
“A wide variety of ingredients in a meal stimulates the microbiome to produce more of the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into dietary stimulation of GLP-1 points to specific ingredients, such as tryptophan-rich protein sources and partially hydrolysed milk proteins, as the best-supported stimulants. The claim that a wide variety of ingredients in a meal specifically increases GLP-1 production finds no support in the available evidence. The link between a diverse microbiome and GLP-1 has not been demonstrated; the broader relationship between the gut microbiome and satiety hormones comes largely from association studies and animal research, and is too general to substantiate this specific claim.
Partly
“An excess of fructose from concentrated sweeteners is stored around the liver and is the primary driver of fatty liver disease.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Fructose does indeed put more strain on the liver than glucose and raises triglycerides and abdominal fat more, which promotes fatty liver disease. However, the claim goes beyond the evidence on two points: at moderate intakes, direct harm in humans has not yet been conclusively demonstrated, and fructose is not the only driver of fatty liver disease. Excess weight, diabetes and a calorie surplus in general play an equally important role. The claim that fructose is specifically stored "around the liver" is moreover a simplification that the available research does not confirm so precisely.
✗ Does not hold up
“Sleep deprivation and stress shut down the functioning of the intestines.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Sleep deprivation and stress can seriously disrupt the intestines, but "shutting down" goes further than what the research shows. Stress causes abdominal pain, irregular bowel movements, and gastrointestinal complaints in many people, and sleep deprivation affects the diversity of gut bacteria. These are real effects, but a complete shutdown of intestinal function has not been demonstrated. The claim paints a more complete and more serious picture than science currently supports.
Partly
“Ultra-processed foods and toxic oils damage the L-cells and shut down GLP-1 production.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that a high-fat diet, certain fatty acids (such as palmitate), and food additives such as carrageenan can disrupt the functioning of L-cells and reduce GLP-1 production. Some of this evidence comes from mouse studies and laboratory studies using cultured cells; only a limited portion has been investigated in humans. The claim is partly correct in its direction: ultra-processed foods do indeed contain substances that can harm L-cells. However, "toxic oils" as a separate category is not identified as such in the research, and the claim that GLP-1 production is completely "shut down" goes beyond what studies show: there is reduced secretion and impaired function, not a complete cessation.
Partly
“Short-chain fatty acids directly stimulate the L-cells in the intestinal wall to produce the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Dietary fibres and their fermentation products, including short-chain fatty acids, are associated with higher GLP-1 secretion, but the direct mechanism via L-cells has not been well established in humans. Research into fibres and GLP-1 in humans is also limited: studies using dietary fibres such as oat bran have so far only been conducted in people who had undergone gastric surgery. The direction of the claim is therefore plausible, but the word "directly" goes beyond what the available evidence in humans can firmly support.
Partly
“GLP-1 agonists strongly slow down digestion, causing hunger to disappear and nausea to occur with larger meals”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several review studies in humans confirm that GLP-1 medications (a group of drugs that affect the pancreas and the brain) slow down gastric emptying, suppress hunger and cause nausea as a common side effect. That direction is therefore correct. However, the claim states that the slower gastric emptying is "strong" and directly causes hunger to "disappear", whereas the studies show that the disappearance of hunger also works through processes in the brain that have nothing to do with how quickly the stomach empties. Moreover, animal research shows that the brain regions that regulate satiety and those that cause nausea are separate from each other. This means that nausea does not simply have to be a consequence of larger meals alone, but operates in its own way. The claim oversimplifies the whole picture and places too much emphasis on slower gastric emptying as the explanation for both effects.
Partly
“To stimulate GLP-1, you only need 10 grams of fermentable fibre per day”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that fermentable fibres can stimulate GLP-1, but no clear threshold of 10 grams per day has been established anywhere. One study in humans did use 10 grams per day of a specific fibre-propionate compound and observed a rise in GLP-1, but this applied to that particular substance, not to fermentable fibres in general. A large review of 52 studies in humans concludes that the effects vary considerably by fibre type and that the results are not consistent. The claim suggests a universal and precise daily dose that the evidence does not support. → How can you naturally stimulate GLP-1 through diet?
Partly
“Ultra-processed food causes more fatigue, poorer sleep, more acid reflux and more frequent infections due to a deterioration of the immune system.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Ultra-processed food is associated in observational research with increased risks of diabetes, cardiovascular disease, depression and premature death, and there are indications that high sugar intake damages the gut lining and chronically stimulates immune cells. However, fatigue, poorer sleep and acid reflux as separate consequences are not firmly established by the available research. The immune effect is plausible with structurally excessive sugar intake, but even then, "more frequent infections" goes a step further than what the evidence shows. The claim combines a range of complaints as though they are all equally well supported, whereas the evidence for most of those specific effects has not been demonstrated.
✗ Does not hold up
“The use of GLP-1 receptor agonists is associated with an increased risk of osteoporosis, bone loss, and bone fractures.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
Research into diabetes and bone fractures shows that GLP-1 agonists have a neutral to mildly beneficial effect on bone health, not a harmful one. Osteoporosis and bone fractures are listed as risks for other diabetes medications, but are not linked to GLP-1 agonists as a class. Only one human trial has been registered, and it was terminated early, which does not point to a strong suspicion of harm. The claim therefore goes against the direction of the available evidence.
Partly
“Vitamin D supplementation improves handgrip strength in postmenopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Multiple systematic reviews of carefully designed studies in postmenopausal women show conflicting results: one review finds a clear improvement in handgrip strength, while two other reviews find no effect whatsoever. A separate carefully designed study in postmenopausal women with HIV does find an improvement in leg strength, but does not measure handgrip strength. A recent carefully designed study even finds no benefit of vitamin D supplements over a placebo for leg muscle function. Further subgroup analyses suggest that any effect on handgrip strength may occur only in certain groups, such as women over 60, women not taking calcium supplements, or women with adequate vitamin D levels at the start of the study. The claim is therefore too broad: whether vitamin D improves handgrip strength depends strongly on the dose, the duration, and the individual characteristics of the woman.
Partly
“A drop in oestrogen levels reduces the insulin sensitivity of muscles.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Animal research shows that oestrogen deficiency is associated with reduced insulin sensitivity in muscles: ovariectomy in female rats worsened insulin-stimulated glucose uptake in muscle tissue, and in male rats too, a lack of sex hormones led to poorer glucose uptake in muscle. A review study notes that oestrogen deficiency in both rodents and humans contributes to insulin resistance. At the same time, one mouse study in which oestrogen receptor signalling was specifically switched off in muscle tissue showed no worsening of glucose uptake in muscles, indicating that the effect is more complex than the claim suggests. In humans, this direct link in muscles has not yet been demonstrated in controlled studies.
Partly
“Good, healthy coffee can stimulate autophagy.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that coffee and caffeine can stimulate autophagy, but the evidence comes largely from animal and laboratory studies. One study shows that in mice, drinking coffee triggers autophagy in the liver, muscle and heart within as little as one to four hours, and that this also applies to decaffeinated coffee. Other studies confirm the autophagy-stimulating effect of caffeine in cells and in animals. Whether this effect also occurs in humans after drinking regular coffee has not yet been demonstrated in these studies. Moreover, the claim concerns 'good, healthy coffee' as a whole, whereas the research focuses on caffeine as an isolated substance or on coffee in animals. → What does caffeine do to your cells and their repair process?
Partly
“Interval training improves endothelial function and makes blood vessels more flexible.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into HIIT shows that it improves cardiorespiratory fitness, including in people with cardiovascular disease, but the available evidence concerns fitness and blood pressure, not endothelial function or vascular flexibility specifically. Those two are related but distinct outcomes, and presenting both as improved goes beyond what the available evidence concretely supports. The direction is plausible, but the precise claim that blood vessels become more supple cannot currently be substantiated.
Partly
“Resistance training significantly reduces body fat percentage, fat mass and visceral fat in healthy adults without changes in diet.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A large study that summarised and analysed 58 earlier studies in healthy adults shows that strength training clearly reduces body fat percentage, fat mass and fat around the organs compared to people who do not exercise. This supports the core of the claim. However, the studies did not always strictly monitor whether participants also changed their eating habits, which means that the condition 'without changes in diet' has not been conclusively demonstrated. Moreover, another large review study shows that endurance training and a combination of endurance and strength training are more effective than strength training alone at reducing total fat mass, which puts the magnitude of the effect of strength training by itself into perspective.
Partly
“When oestrogen levels decline after the age of forty, this directly leads to an increase in insulin resistance.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in women shows that insulin sensitivity decreases after the menopause: women are more sensitive to insulin than men before the menopause, but this advantage gradually disappears after it. Research into women with premature menopause also shows that they have higher fasting glucose levels and marginally higher insulin levels. The claim is therefore broadly correct, but the direction is more accurate than the wording: it is not a matter of a direct or immediate increase as soon as you turn forty, but of a gradual process around and after the menopause. In addition, other factors such as changes in body composition also play a role, and the age threshold of forty is not found as a fixed boundary in the research.
Partly
“Regular sauna sessions of 20 to 30 minutes prepare the body for stress and improve the physiological stress response.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans shows that sauna bathing triggers physiological stress responses, such as an increased heart rate and elevated cortisol levels after the session. One study involving female athletes shows that after six weeks of regular sauna use, the cortisol response and heart rate adaptation improve, which points to an adaptation of the stress system. Nevertheless, the studies are small in scale and examine a variety of types of exercise and sauna protocols; they do not specifically address sessions of 20 to 30 minutes as an optimal duration. The claim that sauna bathing "prepares the body for stress" as a general conclusion therefore goes somewhat beyond what the studies demonstrate.
Partly
“A disrupted balance between omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids stimulates the growth of visceral fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that a high omega-6 to omega-3 ratio is associated with greater fat storage and a higher risk of obesity, and that a better balance can counteract this. However, the studies that examined this most directly were conducted in rats and mice, and one study among these focused specifically on visceral fat. In humans, there are prospective studies showing an increased risk of obesity in general, but direct effects on visceral fat have not yet been demonstrated in humans in the studies available here. The claim therefore goes somewhat beyond what the evidence in humans firmly establishes, particularly regarding the specific effect on visceral fat.
Partly
“When oestrogen levels drop during menopause, the body's natural creatine stores also decline.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Human research shows that women around menopause have lower creatine levels in the brain than younger adults, and that muscle creatine is associated with oestradiol levels during the menstrual cycle. This suggests that oestrogen does indeed influence the body's creatine stores. However, the claim that creatine stores generally decline as oestrogen levels fall goes beyond what the research demonstrates: the brain study is small (twelve women) and cross-sectional, and the muscle study looked at young women in different phases of their cycle, not at women going through menopause. Whether the body as a whole produces or stores less creatine as a result of menopause has therefore not yet been directly demonstrated.
Partly
“Exposure to the herbicide glyphosate on crops can lead to non-Hodgkin lymphoma.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Several meta-analyses have examined the link between glyphosate and non-Hodgkin lymphoma, but the results are contradictory. Some studies find a moderately elevated risk with intensive exposure, others find no association, and the association sometimes disappears when correcting for simultaneous exposure to other pesticides. The claim that glyphosate "can lead to" lymph node cancer therefore goes beyond what the evidence supports: a small elevated risk cannot be ruled out, but cause and effect have not been demonstrated.
✗ Does not hold up
“An increase of one gram of sodium intake per day in a diet of unprocessed food is associated with an increase in healthy life expectancy of 2.6 years.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research actually shows the opposite: eating more salt increases the risk of cardiovascular disease and stroke, and reducing salt intake lowers blood pressure and the risk of premature death. This is one of the best-supported findings in nutritional research. The claim that an extra gram of sodium per day would extend healthy life expectancy by 2.6 years, even in a diet of unprocessed food, is not supported by the available evidence and runs counter to the direction that evidence points.
✗ Does not hold up
“Improving the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio to 4:1 reduces mortality from cardiovascular disease by 70%.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The claim combines two specific assertions: that a 4:1 omega-6/omega-3 ratio is the target, and that this reduces cardiovascular mortality by 70%. Available research shows that omega-3 supplements do not demonstrably lower overall mortality, and that the promising results from earlier studies turned out to be considerably smaller in more rigorous trials. A 70% reduction in cardiovascular mortality is not supported by the research; this figure cannot be substantiated. The notion that the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio in the Western diet is unfavourable has some basis, but that is something quite different from a proven reduction in mortality of that magnitude.
Partly
“Visceral fat is independently associated with a 60% higher risk of a heart attack or stroke.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in humans does indeed show that visceral fat is independently associated with a higher risk of cardiovascular disease, including heart attacks and strokes, so the direction of the claim is correct. However, the specific figure of a 60% higher risk cannot be found in these studies: the risk estimates vary widely depending on the measurement method, the population studied and the combination of risk factors. Moreover, some studies measure waist circumference or indirect fat indices rather than visceral fat directly, which makes comparison difficult. The claim therefore goes beyond what the studies collectively support. → How dangerous is belly fat?
Partly
“After a period of fasting, resuming food intake (refeeding) triggers a strong revival and regeneration of intestinal stem cells.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in mice shows that resuming food intake after a period of fasting does indeed trigger a strong revival of intestinal stem cells: their capacity to divide increases considerably. This effect has been demonstrated in several mouse studies, one of which was published in Nature. The claim is therefore correct in its direction, but incomplete, because the same research also shows that this revival is accompanied by an increased risk of tumour formation in the intestine. Moreover, the effect has so far only been studied in mice and not yet in humans, so the claim goes beyond what the evidence currently supports. → Does intermittent fasting help your gut health?
Partly
“Eating more fibre is associated with better insulin sensitivity in the liver and in adipose tissue.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
An observational study of 44 adults with metabolic syndrome shows that a higher intake of insoluble fibre is associated with a better hepatic insulin response, which supports the first part of the claim. For adipose tissue specifically, however, the available research does not demonstrate this association: a randomised controlled trial actually found that fibre supplements combined with a high-protein diet reduced the insulin response in peripheral tissues, including adipose tissue, and meta-analyses focus on general measures such as fasting insulin and a standard blood marker of insulin action, not on adipose tissue separately. The claim is therefore broader than what the evidence shows, and the association with the liver is moreover based on observational data and has not yet been confirmed in interventional studies.
Partly
“Eating proteins and vegetables first and carbohydrates last reduces the post-meal blood sugar peak by around 44% in people with type 2 diabetes.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research confirms that eating carbohydrates last, after vegetables and protein, measurably reduces the post-meal blood sugar peak, and that this effect is greatest in people with type 2 diabetes. However, that precise figure of 44% cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available evidence. The direction of the claim is correct, but the specific number creates a false sense of precision that the research does not support.
Partly
“Ketones released during fasting inhibit muscle breakdown.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There is research suggesting that ketones can inhibit muscle breakdown, but the evidence is mixed and not conclusive in humans. A study in ten healthy men showed that a ketone infusion strongly reduced muscle breakdown during inflammation. Laboratory research with isolated muscle tissue from rats shows similar effects. However, an older rat study found that ketones had no effect on muscle protein breakdown in the lab. A recent review study concludes that the effects are promising but that further research is needed, and animal and laboratory studies do not always show the same results as studies in humans. The claim points in the right direction, but implies more certainty than the available evidence justifies.
Partly
“Intermittent fasting combined with protein pacing reduces fat around the organs by a third.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
One study in people with obesity (n=41) shows that the combination of intermittent fasting and protein pacing reduced visceral fat by 33%, which corresponds to 'a third'. A second study that looked at protein pacing with caloric restriction alone also found a 33% reduction in visceral fat. The claim is therefore not without basis, but rests on a small study whose lead researcher has financial ties to the sponsor. Broader review studies on intermittent fasting do show fat reduction, but do not confirm the specific figure of a third for this particular combination.
Partly
“The bacterium Lactobacillus plantarum helps reduce obesity”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several review studies summarising the results of well-designed human trials show that Lactobacillus plantarum leads to a modest but clear reduction in body weight, BMI and waist circumference in overweight adults. The claim is therefore broadly correct, but the effects are small and the evidence for some outcomes (such as blood lipids and inflammatory markers) is still weak. Moreover, the reviews show that the results depend strongly on the bacterial strain used, the combination with other strains and the duration of treatment, which makes the claim too categorical. One study was also conducted in mice, and a review article points out that combined bacterial therapies in humans have not yet been sufficiently confirmed.
✓ Holds up
“Ordinary room light before bedtime delays the rise of melatonin in 99 percent of people and shortens its duration by 90 minutes”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A study of 116 healthy adults shows that exposure to ordinary room light (less than 200 lux) in the eight hours before bedtime delayed the rise in melatonin in 99% of participants and shortened the duration of melatonin production by approximately 90 minutes. These are exactly the figures cited in the claim. The other studies confirm in general terms that evening light disrupts melatonin secretion and the circadian rhythm in humans, but add no contradicting evidence. The claim accurately reflects the findings of this specific study.
Partly
“Magnesium stimulates the production of GABA, a neurotransmitter that calms the body and brain”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that magnesium influences the GABA system, but not in the way the claim suggests. Magnesium works primarily by making the receptors for GABA in the brain more sensitive to this substance, and indirectly stimulates its release, but there is no evidence that it increases the production of GABA. One review study in humans describes that magnesium can stimulate the release of GABA and influence how GABA acts in the brain, and research in mice shows that the calming effect of magnesium is linked to these GABA receptors. The claim that magnesium has a calming effect through the GABA system is therefore supported, but the specific claim that it stimulates the production of GABA has not yet been demonstrated. → Does magnesium really help you sleep better?
Partly
“Eating fruit three to four times a week considerably reduces the risk of dying from cardiovascular disease”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Large long-term studies and reviews of multiple studies show that eating more fruit is associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease and premature death. However, the evidence concerns quantities per day, expressed in grams, rather than the number of eating occasions per week as implied by 'three to four times'. Moreover, the studies consistently focus on fruit and vegetables combined, or on dietary patterns in general, and the risk decreases gradually the more you eat, without a specific threshold of three to four times a week emerging from the data. The claim therefore points in the right direction, but is more specific than what the research actually demonstrates.
Partly
“Cooling cooked rice in the refrigerator increases its resistant starch content and blunts the blood sugar response.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Several studies show that cooling cooked rice in the refrigerator increases its resistant starch content, and two studies in humans also demonstrate a lower blood sugar response after eating chilled (and reheated) rice. The claim is therefore broadly correct, but it misses an important nuance: the effect is strongest when the rice is reheated after cooling, and the degree of reduction varies depending on storage duration and temperature. In addition, a study in people with type 1 diabetes warns that chilled rice combined with a standard insulin dose may actually more often lead to low blood sugar. The claim suggests a simple and entirely positive effect, whereas the evidence is somewhat more nuanced.
✗ Does not hold up
“People who use GLP-1 medications have a 29% higher chance of developing osteoporosis.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Multiple studies in humans, including large review studies that pool many individual studies and long-term follow-up studies in large groups of people, show precisely the opposite of what the claim states. One review of 25 randomised controlled trials found no increased risk of fractures, and a large real-world follow-up study in patients with diabetes showed a clearly lower risk of osteoporosis in users of GLP-1 medications. Another large review of more than 1.2 million people likewise found no effect on bone density or fractures. Only tirzepatide, a specific drug that also acts on another hormone, showed an increased risk in one study compared to other GLP-1 medications. There is no study in the research that demonstrates a 29% increased risk of osteoporosis for GLP-1 users as a group.
✓ Holds up
“The hormone GLP-1 suppresses hunger”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Multiple review studies in humans confirm that GLP-1 suppresses hunger and food intake. The hormone is produced after a meal and acts both via the brain and via the intestinal wall to reduce appetite and food intake. One review even describes GLP-1 as a "physiological regulator of appetite and food intake". The claim is therefore well supported by research in humans. → Does GLP-1 help you feel less hungry?
Partly
“Foods high in fibre, proteins, polyphenols and fermented products stimulate the body's own production of GLP-1 in the gut.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
Proteins, in particular tryptophan-rich sources and partially broken-down milk proteins, have demonstrably raised GLP-1 in small studies. For fibres, oat bran is promising, but research into this has so far only been conducted in people who had undergone gastric surgery. For polyphenols and fermented products, there is no direct evidence that they stimulate GLP-1 production: studies on fermented foods focus on gut health in a broader sense, not specifically on GLP-1. The claim is therefore partially correct for proteins and possibly for fibres, but goes beyond the available evidence for polyphenols and fermented products.
Partly
“Walking stimulates the production of the GLP-1 hormone in men.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
In a small study, moderate exercise had no measurable effect on GLP-1, which immediately puts the claim into perspective. The nutritional responses do address GLP-1 stimulation, but contain no evidence that walking specifically increases the production of this hormone in men. The sex-specific claim therefore cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research.
Partly
“A low magnesium level in the body increases susceptibility to stress.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in both humans and animals does indeed show a link between low magnesium levels and greater sensitivity to stress. A review study describes how magnesium deficiency and stress reinforce each other in a cycle: deficiency makes you more susceptible to stress, and stress depletes your magnesium reserves further. Studies in mice show that a low-magnesium diet leads to more anxiety-related behaviour and an overactive stress axis. The claim is therefore broadly correct, but an important detail is missing: this relationship also works in the other direction, as stress itself lowers your magnesium levels. The claim is thus one-sided and implies more certainty about cause and effect than the evidence in humans justifies. → Does a magnesium deficiency make you more sensitive to stress?
Partly
“Eating two to three portions of wild oily fish per week can relieve hot flushes and mood swings during menopause.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
Research in women shows a mixed picture for hot flushes: some studies find a beneficial effect of omega-3 on the frequency of hot flushes and night sweats, while other studies find no clear benefit. An observational study finds a link between eating oily fish and less severe hot flushes, but this link was partly explained by vitamin B6, not exclusively by omega-3. For mood swings and depression, the evidence is still unclear: a small study without a comparison group shows promising results, but larger and better-designed studies do not give a consistent answer. Moreover, all the research concerns omega-3 supplements or oily fish in general, not specifically wild oily fish in quantities of two to three portions per week. → What helps against menopause symptoms like hot flushes and mood swings?
✗ Does not hold up
“Eating 10 grams of ground flaxseed daily reduces menopausal symptoms such as hot flushes, mood swings and insomnia.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Several well-designed studies in which postmenopausal women were randomly assigned to groups and in which some participants unknowingly received a placebo show that flaxseed does not reduce hot flushes and menopausal symptoms any better than such a placebo. A review of eleven intervention studies concludes that there was no meaningful difference between flaxseed and the placebo when it comes to hot flushes and menopausal symptom scores. A large study of similar design and a Brazilian placebo-controlled study also confirm that flaxseed works no better than a placebo pill at reducing hot flushes and broader menopausal symptoms. The claim that eating flaxseed daily reduces hot flushes, mood swings and insomnia is therefore not supported by research in humans. → What helps against menopause symptoms like hot flushes and mood swings?
Partly
“Eating a whole avocado instead of carbohydrates reduces hunger for up to six hours by stimulating the production of GLP-1 and PYY.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
One study in overweight adults shows that eating a whole avocado as a replacement for carbohydrates at breakfast suppressed hunger for up to six hours and raised both PYY and GLP-1 levels. That finding is consistent with the claim. However, in the other study, also in overweight people, there was actually no increase in GLP-1 in the avocado variant where carbohydrates were replaced, and the role of GLP-1 was more limited than that of PYY. Moreover, the lead researcher of the most supportive study has an advisory role at an avocado organisation, which limits her independence. The claim is therefore correct in its direction, but the evidence is not clear-cut enough to be so categorical about both the six-hour duration and the specific role of GLP-1.
Too early
“Pectin in apple skins supports the production of the hormone GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in rats and mice consistently shows that pectin stimulates the release of GLP-1. One study using isolated rat tissue demonstrated that pectin directly triggers GLP-1 release, and animal experiments with rats and mice showed increased blood GLP-1 levels after consuming pectin. A review article also describes how pectin promotes GLP-1 production via gut bacteria and their breakdown products. All of this research was conducted in animals or isolated tissue; whether pectin from apple skins raises GLP-1 production in humans has not yet been tested in human studies. → How can you naturally stimulate GLP-1 through diet?
✓ Holds up
“Letting boiled potatoes cool in the refrigerator for at least 12 hours increases their resistant starch content.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that boiled potatoes stored in the refrigerator contain more resistant starch than freshly cooked potatoes. One study, for example, found an almost 2.8-fold increase in resistant starch after a night of cooling at 4 degrees. Another study compared potatoes that cooled for 1 hour at room temperature with potatoes that spent 24 hours in the refrigerator, and there too the content after 24 hours was clearly higher. This effect is due to retrogradation: as the potatoes cool, the starch forms a more compact structure that is less easily digested. The claim is therefore broadly correct, although the studies do not explicitly examine whether 12 hours is the minimum time required; the threshold found in research is more like overnight or 24 hours.
Partly
“Gentle forms of exercise such as yoga, tai chi, walking and jogging are the most effective against insomnia.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
Walking, jogging and yoga have indeed been studied in relation to sleep and mood problems, and there is evidence that they can help. However, the claim that gentle forms of exercise are the MOST effective against insomnia goes beyond what the evidence justifies: cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) is recommended in multiple guidelines as the best-supported and most effective approach, superior to any form of exercise. Exercise is a valuable addition, but it is not the frontrunner in the evidence on insomnia.
Partly
“Caffeine reduces total sleep time by 45 minutes.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That caffeine disrupts sleep is well established: research shows that a high intake can still make it harder to fall asleep even 12 hours later. However, the claim that it reduces total sleep time by exactly 45 minutes cannot be substantiated. The size of the effect depends strongly on the dose and on genetically determined sensitivity, which varies considerably from person to person.
✗ Does not hold up
“People who eat one hour before bedtime lie awake at night almost twice as long as those who eat five hours before bedtime.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Eating late is indeed associated with poorer sleep and lying awake longer, but the specific figure of "almost twice as long" cannot be substantiated. Research shows a consistent pattern: the closer to bedtime you eat, the more trouble falling asleep and the poorer the sleep quality. However, these effects have been demonstrated without the sharp comparison between one and five hours before bedtime that the claim makes. The claim therefore goes beyond what the evidence supports.
✗ Does not hold up
“Taking 250 milligrams of magnesium bisglycinate daily for four weeks reduces insomnia complaints by 28 %.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Magnesium glycinate (the same as magnesium bisglycinate) can modestly improve sleep, but the evidence is conflicting and of low quality. That precise figure of 28 % after four weeks cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research, and the best available research points rather to a period of use of eight to twelve weeks for meaningful results. One clinical trial in humans is currently under way, but it has not yet produced published results, so the claim goes beyond what the research currently allows.
Partly
“Artificial sweeteners disrupt hunger signals to the brain and kill gut microbes that produce GLP-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
That artificial sweeteners can affect the gut flora has been shown in animal and laboratory research, but in healthy humans this effect has not been found consistently and there is no scientific consensus. The specific mechanism mentioned in the claim, namely that gut microbes producing GLP-1 are killed, goes beyond what the available research in humans shows. As for the disruption of hunger signals to the brain, nothing in the research supports this claim. The general thrust of the claim is therefore not entirely without basis, but the wording is more assertive than the evidence allows.
Partly
“Dietary fibres suppress blood sugar spikes and stimulate gut bacteria to produce GLP-1, short-chain fatty acids and serotonin.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
The claim that fibres suppress blood sugar spikes and stimulate gut bacteria is correct: soluble fibres demonstrably lower blood sugar after a meal, and certain fibres such as fructans and galacto-oligosaccharides reliably feed beneficial bacteria like Bifidobacterium. However, the claim goes beyond the evidence on two points. That gut bacteria also produce serotonin via fibres is not supported by the research available on this topic. Short-chain fatty acids and GLP-1 are indeed suggested in the context of fibres and gut bacteria, but have not been established as proven endpoints in humans in the available studies. The direction is right, but the complete chain from fibres to all those substances at once has not been demonstrated as directly as the claim suggests.
Partly
“GLP-1 slows down digestion and stimulates the pancreas to release insulin, keeping blood sugar levels stable.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
GLP-1 does indeed stimulate the pancreas to secrete insulin, thereby helping to regulate blood sugar. The slowing of digestion is a well-known effect of GLP-1, but this part of the claim is not addressed in the available research. As for the pancreas, studies show that GLP-1 agonists promote insulin release in humans, but recovery or regeneration of pancreatic cells in humans has not yet been demonstrated. The claim paints the mechanism as slightly too simple and complete, while the nuances in the science have not yet been fully worked out.
Partly
“Taking a daily soy isoflavone supplement reduces menopausal symptoms during perimenopause by 38 percent after 12 weeks.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Soy isoflavones can indeed reduce hot flashes, but the research points to an average effect of around 20 percent and roughly one fewer hot flash per day, not the 38 percent the claim mentions. Moreover, studies contradict each other enough on this point to cast considerable uncertainty over that figure. No demonstrable effect has been found on menopausal symptoms beyond hot flashes alone, whereas the claim refers to "menopausal symptoms" in general. The precise duration of 12 weeks and the percentage cited cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research.
✗ Does not hold up
“Taking 250 milligrams of magnesium bisglycinate daily reduces the insomnia score in adults by 28 % after four weeks.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That magnesium bisglycinate can modestly improve sleep problems is consistent with what research shows, but that precise figure of 28 % after exactly four weeks cannot be substantiated. The available studies are small, of low quality and partly contradictory; they do not justify a specific number. Moreover, the best available research points to a period of eight to twelve weeks, not four. One registered human trial is currently under way, but it has not yet published any results.
Partly
“Drinking alcohol raises the body's core temperature and thereby disrupts sleep.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That alcohol disrupts sleep is well established: even two glasses impair REM sleep, and with chronic use sleep and recovery become structurally damaged. However, the claim that a raised core temperature is the cause of this is not supported by the available research. Alcohol demonstrably disrupts sleep, but the precise mechanism by which this happens cannot be pinned down on the basis of the available evidence.
✗ Does not hold up
“Looking at the red light of a sunset stimulates the brain to produce melatonin.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research actually shows the opposite: (day)light suppresses melatonin rather than stimulating its production. Melatonin production kicks in when it gets dark, not in response to light exposure, including red light. Morning light helps synchronise the biological clock, which makes it easier to fall asleep earlier in the evening, but that is an indirect effect through the circadian rhythm, not through direct melatonin production triggered by light. The claim that sunset light specifically stimulates melatonin production in the brain has not been demonstrated.
Partly
“Around the age of forty, oestrogen levels in women begin to decline.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, November 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The decline in oestrogen in women is a well-established process, but it does not begin abruptly around the age of forty. The transition is characterised by hormonal fluctuations that occur in the lead-up to the menopause, and oestrogen declines gradually over a longer period. The claim gives the impression that forty is a sharp turning point, whereas research shows that the timing varies considerably from person to person.
Partly
“People who fast on alternate days lose more fat around their organs than those who follow a 16:8 fasting schedule.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Alternate-day fasting does indeed produce greater weight loss than 16:8 in large comparisons, which supports the direction of the claim. However, the claim goes a step further by specifically mentioning visceral fat around the organs: that distinction cannot be firmly established on the basis of the available research. For most metabolic outcomes, including body composition, all forms of intermittent fasting are moreover comparable to ordinary calorie restriction. The difference in weight loss therefore says nothing specific about fat around the organs.
Partly
“Exercising immediately after a meal shortens blood sugar spikes and reduces fat storage”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Exercising after a meal demonstrably lowers blood sugar spikes, and this applies even to very short walking breaks of just a few minutes. The first part of the claim therefore holds up. The second part, that exercising immediately after eating also reduces fat storage, is not supported as directly by the research: what we know is that physical activity contributes to tackling abdominal fat, but that effect is linked to an energy deficit and is not specifically tied to the moment immediately after a meal. The claim connects two effects as though both are equally well proven for that one particular moment, while evidence for reduced fat storage after a meal is lacking.
Partly
“Fat around the organs triggers inflammatory responses and makes the body more resistant to insulin”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Excess weight and abdominal fat are indeed associated with chronic inflammation and insulin resistance, and both links are well explained biologically and appear consistently across multiple studies. The claim is therefore broadly correct. What is missing is the specification that it concerns fat around the organs in particular (visceral fat): the available research describes adipose tissue and excess weight in a broader sense, without drawing that distinction sharply. Moreover, the causal relationship, that this fat actively causes the inflammation and resistance, is convincingly plausible but largely based on observational research.
Partly
“From the age of 35, progesterone levels decline, causing levels of the calming substance GABA to decrease as well.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That progesterone can decline before menopause and thereby cause symptoms is consistent with what research shows, but the link with GABA is not supported by the available evidence. The claim assumes a direct chain from progesterone to GABA that has not been scientifically demonstrated in our sources. Moreover, the age threshold of 35 is more specific than the research supports: a decline in progesterone is associated with the period before menopause, but is not pinned to one particular age.
Partly
“Eating 30 to 40 grams of protein every two to three hours feeds the muscles and protects against muscle loss.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The amount of 30 to 40 grams of protein per serving is broadly correct: research supports servings of 20 to 40 grams, spread throughout the day, as beneficial for muscle maintenance. However, the interval of every two to three hours deviates slightly from what the evidence suggests: spreading intake every three to four hours demonstrably works better than consuming portions too frequently. Furthermore, the protective effect against muscle loss has only been properly demonstrated in combination with strength training; protein alone is considerably less effective. The claim omits this condition and thereby creates a somewhat rosier picture than the research justifies.
Partly
“Getting too little sleep reduces insulin sensitivity.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research into sleep and diabetes shows that chronically sleeping too little increases the risk of type 2 diabetes, and there are indications that this relationship is also causal. That strongly suggests that insulin sensitivity plays a role, as it is a core mechanism in the development of diabetes. The available findings confirm the link between sleep deprivation and disrupted blood sugar regulation, but do not directly support the specific effect on insulin sensitivity. The claim is therefore plausible, but goes slightly further than what the available evidence strictly establishes.
✗ Does not hold up
“Resistance training is the most effective form of exercise for people with diabetes to increase insulin sensitivity.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Resistance training does improve insulin sensitivity, but the research actually shows that a combination of strength and endurance training produces the strongest results in people with diabetes, not resistance training on its own. Claiming that it is the most effective form of exercise goes beyond what the evidence shows: there is no study in which resistance training comes out on top. The strongest support applies to a combined programme, supplemented by attention to diet.
Partly
“In women with chronic stress, eating foods high in sugar and fat is associated with more abdominal fat and insulin resistance.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Chronic stress demonstrably increases the accumulation of deep abdominal fat through prolonged elevated cortisol levels and promotes insulin resistance; stress is also associated with greater cravings for fatty and sugary foods. These two lines thus run in parallel, but the available research largely treats them separately: the effect of cortisol on abdominal fat is well established, whereas the evidence that stress-related eating behaviour in women specifically leads to more abdominal fat and insulin resistance is not yet conclusive. The claim combines these two mechanisms into a single direct relationship that research has not yet fully confirmed as a whole.
Partly
“GLP-1 weight loss drugs can lead to loss of vision, muscle mass, and bone density”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Muscle loss with GLP-1 drugs is well documented: roughly a quarter of the weight lost consists of muscle and other non-fat tissue. That part of the claim rests on solid ground. The available research says nothing about loss of bone density, and the same applies to loss of vision. Those two claims therefore cannot be substantiated on the basis of current evidence, which means the statement as a whole goes beyond what has been demonstrated.
Partly
“Eating fermented food for ten weeks increases gut microbial diversity and lowers 19 inflammatory markers in the blood.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
A randomised study does indeed show that a diet rich in fermented foods increases microbiome diversity and lowers inflammatory markers, and this direction is confirmed by multiple studies. The specific details in the claim, namely ten weeks and exactly 19 inflammatory markers, cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available evidence. Moreover, the evidence comes primarily from smaller studies, meaning this result does not yet hold up as broadly established.
Partly
“A higher intake of dietary fibre is linked to a lower body weight and improved metabolic health.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Fibre demonstrably contributes to better blood sugar regulation and protects the intestinal wall through short-chain fatty acids, which is consistent with the idea of improved metabolic health. However, a direct link between higher fibre intake and lower body weight is not established in the available research. The effects on gut flora and the immune system also vary considerably from person to person, and large randomised evidence is still lacking for broad health claims.
Partly
“Time-restricted eating or intermittent fasting for 15 to 16 hours improves insulin sensitivity, blood pressure, inflammation, and mitochondrial health.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that intermittent fasting improves insulin sensitivity in most people and also has positive effects on weight and cardiovascular risk, but the studies are predominantly small and short-term. The claim regarding blood pressure and inflammation goes beyond what the available evidence supports, and for mitochondrial health there is no basis to be found in the available human studies. Furthermore, the specific time window of 15 to 16 hours has not been established as a threshold in the studies that demonstrate positive effects.
✗ Does not hold up
“2.5 grams of hydrolysed chicken collagen per day reduces joint pain and stiffness by 36.9%.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The general direction of the claim, that hydrolysed collagen can reduce joint pain, is supported by research, but most of the other details are incorrect. Studies typically use around ten grams per day, not 2.5 grams, and they concern hydrolysed collagen in general, not specifically the chicken variety. The precise figure of 36.9 percent reduction cannot be found in the available evidence. Moreover, that kind of exact number is a sign of false precision: studies do show a positive trend, but outcomes vary from study to study and from population to population.
Partly
“Fasting for 16 hours regulates the immune system and lowers inflammatory markers.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into intermittent fasting shows that fasting can lower inflammatory markers and has a positive effect on metabolic risk factors such as weight, blood pressure and blood sugar, which may indirectly benefit the immune system. However, the specific duration of 16 hours is not firmly supported by evidence, and whether fasting also leads to better clinical immune outcomes, such as fewer infections or remission of immune diseases, has not yet been demonstrated. The general direction is correct as far as inflammatory markers are concerned, but the claim presents more certainty than the evidence provides.
✓ Holds up
“Hormonal changes during and after the menopause cause women to store more visceral fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, October 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Declining oestrogen levels during and after menopause demonstrably promote the accumulation of abdominal fat, which includes visceral fat around the organs. Observational and mechanistic research supports this link fairly consistently: lower oestrogen impairs insulin sensitivity and promotes fat accumulation around the abdomen, while that abdominal fat in turn further disrupts metabolism. The evidence does, however, rest largely on observational research, so not everything can yet be said about the precise magnitude of the effect.
Partly
“Creatine supplementation increases lean muscle mass, even without exercise, and enhances the effects of resistance training.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in November 2026 · stated with confidence
The evidence that creatine enhances the effects of resistance training is solid: multiple reviews confirm improvements in strength and muscle mass in the context of intensive training. However, the part of the claim stating that creatine increases lean muscle mass without training is not supported by the evidence. The strongest findings apply specifically to the combination with regular resistance training, and the same holds for protein supplementation: training is a necessary condition for maintaining or building muscle mass. The independent effect of creatine on muscle mass outside a training context has not been demonstrated.
Partly
“A minimum of 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of target body weight per day is needed to prevent muscle loss.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The range of 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram per day is well supported for maintaining muscle mass, but the claim goes beyond the evidence on two points. First, this recommendation is based on total body weight, not specifically on target body weight. Second, resistance training is a crucial factor in the underlying research: protein alone is considerably less effective at preventing muscle loss. Furthermore, the word "minimum" implies a hard lower threshold, whereas the studies show an optimal range rather than an absolute cut-off point.
Partly
“Following a fasting-mimicking diet for five days each month over three consecutive months can regenerate beta cells in the pancreas in type 1 diabetes.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A small pilot study provides preliminary indications that a fasting-mimicking diet may have cell-rejuvenating effects, including the restoration of certain cell types, but whether beta cells in the pancreas actually regenerate in people with type 1 diabetes has not yet been demonstrated in large, well-designed studies. The findings come largely from animal research, and the translation to humans has not yet been sufficiently established. The claim presents as settled fact what is, for now, a promising but unconfirmed hypothesis.
Partly
“Five consecutive days of a fasting-mimicking diet reduce body weight, waist circumference, systolic blood pressure, and inflammatory markers such as IGF-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
A fasting-mimicking diet improves several health markers, including weight, waist circumference, and inflammatory markers, as small randomised studies show. IGF-1 is typically included as an outcome in that research, but whether it actually decreases cannot be firmly established on the basis of the available evidence. The same applies to systolic blood pressure: the direction appears favourable, but the claim presents the combination of effects more categorically than the studies justify. In addition, several of the researchers involved have financial ties to the commercial product, which calls for caution when interpreting the findings.
✗ Does not hold up
“Plant-based seed oils such as rapeseed, cottonseed, and soybean oil raise blood pressure and cause disease.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research actually shows the opposite: seed oils such as sunflower oil lower bad cholesterol and are associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease, especially compared to saturated fats. The claim that they raise blood pressure or cause disease is not supported by research in humans. The argument that seed oils promote inflammation, a commonly heard justification for this type of claim, also finds no support in the available research.
Partly
“Creatine supplementation combined with resistance training improves both body composition and physical performance in post-menopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Creatine combined with resistance training demonstrably improves muscle strength in older adults, and the initial findings in postmenopausal women are promising. However, the claim goes slightly beyond what the evidence supports: for this specific group, large long-term studies are lacking, and the effects on body composition and broader physical performance have not been established firmly enough to speak of a proven combined effect. The direction is right, but the evidence is currently too limited to support the claim in its entirety.
Partly
“Intensive interval training stimulates the production of growth hormone, which promotes fat burning and slows down ageing.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in October 2026 · stated with confidence
Exercise, including intensive training, demonstrably raises growth hormone and other anabolic hormones in older adults, although the extent varies considerably from person to person. The leap to fat burning and the slowing of ageing goes beyond what the available evidence can firmly support: for those specific chains of effects, there is no conclusive proof in humans, and the only approaches with solid backing in humans remain exercise in general, adequate protein intake and avoiding overeating. The claim therefore contains a kernel of truth, but presents a series of effects as established fact when the research is too limited or too inconsistent to justify that.
Partly
“Taking an average of around 7,000 steps per day reduces the overall risk of death by 47% compared to 2,000 steps per day.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Large cohort studies do indeed show that the risk of death drops noticeably as you take more steps each day, and the research supports around 7,000 steps as a beneficial target. However, the specific figure of a 47% lower mortality risk compared to 2,000 steps cannot be firmly established on the basis of the available evidence. Moreover, these are observational associations, not demonstrated cause and effect: more active people may lead healthier lives in a number of other ways, which makes a precise percentage claim vulnerable to criticism.
Partly
“Eating at least 30 grams of fibre a day helps prevent insulin resistance.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Eating more fibre is indeed associated with better blood sugar regulation and insulin sensitivity, and a diet high in fibre is one of the best-supported ways to address insulin resistance. However, the threshold of 30 grams is hard to pin down: research points to 25 to 29 grams as a well-supported target, and not every type of fibre works equally well. Moreover, the claim overlooks the fact that other factors, such as physical activity and the rest of one's diet, also play a major role in preventing insulin resistance.
✓ Holds up
“The drop in oestrogen around the menopause increases insulin resistance and promotes the storage of visceral fat.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Declining oestrogen levels around menopause do indeed promote the build-up of abdominal fat and increase the risk of insulin resistance. Observational and mechanistic research supports this relationship fairly consistently: hormonal decline and the accumulation of abdominal fat reinforce each other in a cycle, with the abdominal fat in turn further disrupting metabolism. The evidence is largely based on observational research and large controlled trials are lacking, but the general direction of the claim is well supported.
Partly
“Eating at least 30 different types of plant-based foods every week increases the diversity of the gut microbiome.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
A varied plant-based diet does indeed benefit the gut microbiome, but the evidence for the specific target of 30 different types per week is not well established. What research does show is that a broadly varied diet supports bacterial diversity, although an increased fibre intake only has a measurable effect in people who already have a diverse microbiome. In a controlled study, fermented foods even showed a stronger effect on diversity than a high-fibre diet. The general direction of the claim is correct, but the specific target of 30 is not supported by solid evidence.
Partly
“Prolonged fasting breaks down old immune cells and stimulates stem cells to produce healthier new immune cells during refeeding.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research in animals and small human studies suggests that fasting can activate stem cells and have cell-rejuvenating effects, which supports the general direction of this claim. However, the specific mechanism described, namely that old immune cells are broken down and that stem cells subsequently produce demonstrably healthier new immune cells during refeeding, has not been firmly established in humans through large, well-designed studies. The strongest evidence on the immune effects of fasting concerns reduced inflammatory markers and improved metabolic risk factors, not this precise regenerative process. The claim therefore describes a biologically plausible mechanism, but goes beyond what current evidence in humans supports.
✗ Does not hold up
“To stay in autophagy while fasting, protein intake must remain below 20 grams.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The threshold of 20 grams of protein to preserve autophagy sounds precise, but that level of precision cannot be substantiated. Research shows that no established threshold values exist in humans for activating autophagy, nor for the role of protein intake in that process. Moreover, there is currently no reliable method to measure autophagy in humans, which means that boundaries of this kind cannot be verified in practice. The claim conveys a degree of certainty that the research does not support.
✗ Does not hold up
“After about 15 hours of fasting, growth hormone levels rise, and around 17 hours, autophagy is stimulated.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
For both the growth hormone peak at 15 hours and the autophagy threshold at 17 hours, no clinically established time standard exists for humans. Research shows that fasting can mechanistically trigger autophagy, but several reviews note that even standard intermittent fasting may be too short to measurably increase autophagy. The precise time thresholds stated in the claim cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available evidence.
Partly
“Fasting for 72 hours without food stimulates the release of stem cells and regenerates the immune system.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Animal studies do indeed show that fasting can stimulate stem cell production and has cell-rejuvenating effects, but in humans the evidence is limited to small pilot studies using biomarkers. The idea of a complete 'reset' of the immune system has not been firmly demonstrated: fasting does lower inflammatory markers and has indirect beneficial effects on the immune system through weight and blood sugar, but hard clinical outcomes such as fewer infections or remission of autoimmune diseases have not been sufficiently studied. The specific claim about 72 hours and its link to stem cell release goes beyond what current research in humans confirms.
✗ Does not hold up
“Fermented foods help menopausal women break down oestrogen so that it becomes more usable for the body's cells.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The gut microbiome does indeed play a role in oestrogen metabolism, but the relationship works differently from what the claim suggests. Research shows that changes in the gut microbiome after menopause can further suppress already low oestrogen levels, rather than fermented foods making oestrogen more usable for the body's cells. Proven interventions targeting the gut microbiome in menopausal women do not yet exist, and the idea that fermented foods steer oestrogen breakdown in a way that benefits the user is not supported by the available research.
Partly
“Strength training combined with aerobic training significantly lowers HbA1c levels in the blood.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Combinations of strength and endurance training show the strongest results in improving blood sugar regulation in people with type 2 diabetes, and there are multiple indications that such a combined programme also most effectively improves insulin sensitivity. However, the word 'significantly' goes further than the available evidence justifies: how large the reduction in HbA1c actually is, and whether it is always clinically meaningful, depends strongly on a person's weight, diet and baseline situation. For people who are overweight, diet also plays a greater role than the type of training.
Partly
“Aerobic exercise such as walking lowers HbA1c levels and fasting blood sugar.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that walking after meals measurably reduces blood sugar spikes, and that effect is well supported by multiple randomised studies and meta-analyses. Whether walking also lowers HbA1c levels cannot be established on the basis of the available research into walking: the findings on HbA1c relate exclusively to medication, not to aerobic exercise. The claim therefore holds for fasting blood sugar and blood sugar response, but the link to HbA1c reduction through walking is not supported by the evidence.
Partly
“Combining proteins and fibre in a meal curbs the blood sugar spike and prevents a blood sugar crash.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that soluble fiber lowers blood sugar after a meal, and that the overall composition of the meal plays a role in this. However, the claim that proteins and fiber together specifically prevent a blood sugar crash goes beyond what the available evidence demonstrates. The dampening of the spike is well supported for fiber, but the notion of a 'crash' as a consequence of a spike, and the specific combination with protein, are not confirmed in that way by the research.
Partly
“In addition to muscle recovery, creatine supplementation also improves memory and attention in older adults.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · repeated in September 2026 · stated with confidence
Research shows that creatine can promote muscle recovery in older adults (60+) and may have positive effects on memory, particularly in combination with strength training. However, the evidence for a memory effect is strongest for people aged 66 and older, and the findings on muscle recovery are not entirely consistent. For attention specifically, the evidence is less clear: studies show cognitive benefits under conditions of fatigue or sleep deprivation, but not broadly for all older adults. The claim is largely correct, but is somewhat too categorical about both effects simultaneously.
Partly
“Taking 7,000 steps per day reduces overall mortality by 47% and the risk of type 2 diabetes by 14% compared to 2,000 steps per day.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research does indeed show that more daily steps are associated with a lower risk of death, and that the greatest health benefits occur roughly between 3,500 and 10,000 steps per day. The general direction of the claim is therefore correct. However, the specific figures of a 47% reduction in overall mortality and a 14% reduction in the risk of type 2 diabetes at exactly 7,000 steps compared to 2,000 steps cannot be substantiated on the basis of the available research. Furthermore, these are associations from observational studies, not proven cause and effect.
Partly
“Vitamin K2 as a supplement improves the bone mineral density of the lumbar vertebrae in post-menopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There are encouraging indications that vitamin K2 may improve bone mineral density in postmenopausal women, particularly in combination with vitamin D. However, the results are not fully consistent and the evidence is not strong enough for a broad recommendation. The claim presents the effect as established, whereas the studies describe it as promising but variable.
Partly
“Taking 5 grams of collagen peptides daily increases bone mineral density in post-menopausal women.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, September 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research into hydrolysed collagen peptides (5 g/day) shows positive but limited results for bone density in postmenopausal women. An important caveat is that a considerable share of this evidence comes from industry-funded studies, which limits its reliability. The direction of the claim is correct, but the statement is more definitive than the available research justifies.
✗ Does not hold up
“A 72-hour fasting period resets the entire immune system and activates stem cells”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Research shows that fasting can reduce inflammation markers and indirectly benefit the immune system, but a true 'reset' of the immune system has not been convincingly demonstrated. No evidence was found for a specific 72-hour fasting period activating stem cells. The claim therefore goes far beyond what the available evidence supports.
✓ Holds up
“Eating only one meal a day is linked to an increased risk of dying from all causes and from cardiovascular disease.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with caution
A large 2023 American population study found exactly this association: people who ate one meal a day had higher mortality from all causes and from cardiovascular disease. The claim is also carefully worded as an association. One caveat: this is observational research, so a causal relationship has not been established.
✗ Does not hold up
“Exposure of the eyes to natural light stimulates the body's own production of melatonin.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
This is the wrong way round. Light entering the eyes suppresses melatonin production; an effect that has been measured in a dose-dependent manner, with blue light having the strongest suppressive effect. What is correct is the underlying idea: plenty of daylight during the day synchronises your biological clock, which allows melatonin to kick in at the right time in the evening. But that happens via the clock as an intermediary, not through direct stimulation of melatonin production.
Partly
“Oestrogen stimulates the biological clock in the brain that determines when the body produces melatonin for the sleep-wake cycle.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
That oestrogen influences the biological clock in the brain is plausible and there are indications to support this, primarily from animal research. How significant that influence is in humans, and whether it explains the sleep complaints seen during the menopause, has not been established.
Partly
“Memory loss and learning difficulties during the menopause are directly linked to the neurotransmitter acetylcholine.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
There is a genuine link between oestrogen and the cholinergic system; this has been described in review articles and in primate research, and it is one of the explanations being seriously investigated. 'Directly linked' is too categorical. Memory complaints during the menopause are also associated with poor sleep, hot flushes and mood, and research has been unable to meaningfully disentangle these factors from one another.
Partly
“Red light therapy reduces joint stiffness and accelerates muscle recovery.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
For muscle recovery and muscle soreness after exercise, there is reasonable research suggesting that red light has some effect, though the studies are small and the devices used vary considerably. For joint stiffness, the evidence is thinner. The general direction is not unreasonable, but the claim is stated with too much certainty.
✓ Holds up
“From the age of thirty, muscle mass decreases by an average of 3 to 8 percent per decade.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Correct, this is the standard figure in the literature. From around the age of thirty, you lose 3 to 8 percent of muscle mass every ten years, and after sixty that process accelerates. Strength training slows this down considerably but does not stop it entirely.
Partly
“Ten minutes of resistance exercises spread throughout a workday leads to an increase in muscle mass in women within twelve weeks.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
In people who are not yet training, even ten minutes a day produces measurable gains in strength and fitness. Whether actual muscle mass also increases within twelve weeks is less certain: the studies measuring this are small, and what tends to grow is mainly strength through better muscle coordination, not more muscle tissue.
✓ Holds up
“Short movement breaks after a meal significantly reduce blood sugar and insulin spikes.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Correct, and it is one of the simplest interventions available. A few minutes of movement after eating measurably flattens the blood sugar and insulin spike, because the muscles absorb glucose directly.
Partly
“Frequent muscle contractions raise levels of the enzyme lipoprotein lipase (LPL), which lowers total and LDL cholesterol.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The enzyme is correct and so is the mechanism: sitting for long periods suppresses lipoprotein lipase activity, and moving activates it again. However, that enzyme works mainly on fats in the blood and on good cholesterol, not on LDL. That last step in the claim is incorrect.
✗ Does not hold up
“Fat burning occurs optimally at an intensity of 70% of VO2 max.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
The point at which your body burns the most fat is lower, at around 45 to 65 percent of your maximum effort, and even lower in untrained individuals. At 70 percent you have already passed that point and your body increasingly switches to burning sugar. For anyone training with fat burning as a goal, this advice is therefore off the mark.
Partly
“Short sessions of intense muscle contraction stimulate the production of growth hormone and IGF-1.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Strength exercise produces a peak in growth hormone immediately afterwards, and that is well established. However, this peak is short-lived and turns out not to determine how much muscle you build; that happens through other pathways within the muscle itself. IGF-1, moreover, responds much more slowly and is more strongly linked to your diet.
Partly
“Short bouts of exercise spread throughout the day improve fitness and lower cholesterol levels.”
Dr. Mindy Pelz, August 2026 · watch the episode ↗︎ · stated with confidence
Short bouts of movement spread throughout the day demonstrably improve your fitness, even if you never get around to a proper workout. That is the strongest part of this advice. For cholesterol, the evidence is much thinner: the effects are small and have not been found consistently.
Newsletter

Stay in the loop

Every Thursday, the most important longevity research in your inbox, focused on what you follow.