Alzheimer is largely preventable, says neurologist David Perlmutter
Alzheimer begins decades before diagnosis, says neurologist David Perlmutter, and those are precisely the years when you can still do something about it. His advice holds up and his findings are promising, but they run ahead of the science.
"Imagine you are 85." David Perlmutter asks a packed auditorium to close their eyes. Then he draws an imaginary line down the middle of the room. "Half of you now have dementia. Which half are you in?"
Perlmutter knows what that other half looks like. His father, a gifted brain surgeon, developed Alzheimer's and spent his final years in a care home directly across the parking lot from Perlmutter's neurology practice. From the consulting room, he could see his father's window. "I had nothing to offer him." Perlmutter is now 71. "I am not over it, and I never will be."
Patients' families would sometimes tell him: doctor, you have no idea what we are going through. He would point to that window. "My father lives there, and he is dying of this disease. I understand."
Perlmutter speaks from the clinic, not from the sidelines. He is a neurologist who treated people with Alzheimer's in his own practice and says he has held around a hundred brains in his hands and reviewed thousands of brain scans. He can spot Parkinson's, he says, just from watching someone walk past him at the airport. He is affiliated with the medical faculty of the University of Miami and sits on the editorial board of the Journal of Alzheimer's Disease.
His conclusion is radical: Alzheimer's is largely preventable. Not with a pill, but with the way you live your life from your thirties onward.
What turns a healthy brain bad
"What turns a good brain bad?" That is the question Perlmutter keeps coming back to. For decades, medicine had one answer: amyloid, the protein clumps that accumulate in an Alzheimer's brain. Clear them out and the problem is solved. It does not work that way, he says. There are people whose brains are full of these clumps who never develop dementia.
He sees the research shifting – away from amyloid and toward metabolism – and he is not alone in that view. Of the drugs against Alzheimer's currently being tested in humans, only 18 percent still target amyloid. In England, a large trial with metformin – a diabetes drug now being tested in people with Alzheimer's – got under way this year. And the newer drugs that do clear amyloid have been disappointing. A large review of 17 studies found barely any noticeable effect on memory, alongside higher rates of swelling and bleeding in the brain. Perlmutter is blunt: do not use them.
The evil twin in your head
His own answer starts with the brain's immune cells, the microglia. Under normal conditions they act as maintenance workers: repairing connections between nerve cells and keeping the blood-brain barrier sealed. But they can flip. Perlmutter calls that alternative state "the evil twin" – the same cell, now breaking down connections instead of maintaining them. What triggers the switch? High blood sugar, inflammation, poor sleep, alcohol, physical inactivity, loneliness.
He describes Alzheimer's as "first and foremost a metabolic disease of the brain." The state of your brain, he argues, can be read from the same four markers as the state of your heart: blood sugar, blood pressure, belly fat, and blood lipids.
That microglia play a central role in Alzheimer's is becoming increasingly clear. Many of the genes that raise the risk are active specifically in these cells. But dividing them into a good twin and an evil twin is a simplification – all kinds of intermediate states exist, as Perlmutter himself acknowledges. And whether you can reset them through lifestyle changes has not yet been shown in humans.
He does believe in 40 hertz: light and sound that switch on and off forty times per second. In mice with Alzheimer's, this restores the brain's healthy rhythm and puts microglia back into maintenance mode. In patients, a first small trial found it to be safe, with some signs that it helps. Perlmutter keeps one of these devices next to his own monitor. "Can I prove it is doing something good for me? No. But do I believe in the science? Absolutely." The larger study involving around 670 Alzheimer's patients has concluded, but the results are not yet known.
The most powerful tool costs very little
Perlmutter's most powerful weapon against dementia is a pair of running shoes. "Exercise moves every dial."
On that point, the research is on his side. People who are most physically active in middle age develop dementia around 40 percent less often than those who are least active. People with type 2 diabetes develop dementia noticeably more often, and both poor sleep and limited social contact are linked to higher risk. A tape measure around your waist, he calls "a very expensive, high-tech instrument." And if you carry the gene variant that raises your risk of Alzheimer's, there is no need to despair: "it is a predisposition, not a fate."
Perlmutter would rather talk to people in their thirties than in their eighties, because the earlier you change your habits, the more you can prevent. Alzheimer starts decades before the diagnosis.
Preventable – at least in part
"Largely preventable," Perlmutter says, and sometimes even "almost entirely." International experts put the figure at close to half of all cases. That is enormous – but it is still only half.
That the disease can even be reversed, he supports with an American trial. People with early-stage Alzheimer's changed their diet, exercise, and stress management for twenty weeks. In more than 70 percent of them, their condition stayed the same or improved – "which no medication can achieve." The trial involved 51 people. A small study, he is the first to say. Larger research is needed to find out whether the results hold up.
Hope is not a strategy
"Hope is not a strategy," says Perlmutter. If you wait for a miracle drug, you let slip the very years in which the difference is made. Whether the evil twin is the right explanation still needs to be established by research. But for the question that hung in that auditorium – which half are you in – you do not need that explanation. The prescription already works: exercise, sleep, keep an eye on your blood sugar, and stay connected to the people around you.