Can vitamin C and E supplements reduce the benefits of exercise?
Studies show that taking vitamin C and E daily during a training programme can slow muscle adaptations, particularly in young healthy athletes. People who take the supplements only around a heavy bout of exercise appear to be less affected.
Exercise makes your body stronger because muscles are temporarily damaged by free radicals. That damage sends a signal that triggers recovery and adaptation. Vitamin C and E mop up those free radicals and can therefore block precisely the signalling routes your body uses to get stronger.
That may sound like theory, but it has been demonstrated in practice too. In studies with young men, taking a combination of vitamin C (1 gram per day) and vitamin E (235 mg per day) for three weeks of sprint interval training clearly slowed down the adaptations in the muscles. The muscle fibres that grow the most with this type of training were hit the hardest. Cycling performance improved equally in both groups, but over the longer term this could harm your endurance.
The effect depends heavily on timing. Taking the supplements every day for an extended period during a training programme appears to carry the greatest risk. Taking them acutely, shortly before or during a heavy effort, actually shows benefits in a summary of the available literature: less fatigue and faster recovery. For football players who play many matches in a short space of time, short-term use around match days may support recovery, while prolonged use at high doses can undermine training gains.
There is one important exception. In older women with sarcopenia (age-related muscle loss), vitamin C and E combined with twelve weeks of resistance training produced greater improvements in muscle mass and strength than training with a placebo. In this group the balance between damage and repair is already disturbed, and supplementing with antioxidants appears to be beneficial. This was studied using 1000 mg of vitamin C and 335 mg of vitamin E per day; discuss this with your doctor.
For healthy athletes, the benefits of long-term supplementation have only been shown in people who start with already low antioxidant levels. If that does not apply to you, there is a good chance that taking vitamin C and E every day is actually cutting into your own training results.
This answer draws on a comprehensive summary of the available literature, a controlled study in young male athletes, a study where neither participants nor researchers knew who was taking supplements in older women with muscle loss, and several review papers on antioxidants and athletes. The evidence that long-term supplementation can slow training adaptation is reasonably consistent; the exception for older people with muscle loss is based on one study. For the heart the picture is mixed and no conclusion can be drawn. The researchers themselves note that the quality of the evidence varies by sub-question and that effects depend strongly on timing, dose, duration and the athlete's starting status.
Can intense exercise actually make you age faster?
Regular, well-paced exercise keeps cells measurably younger, as seen in longer telomeres and less DNA damage. How you structure your training determines whether you reap that benefit.
Does exercise raise your apelin levels?
Exercise raises apelin levels in most people, even with short stair-climbing breaks throughout the day. In type 2 diabetes, that effect has not yet been demonstrated.
Does exercise really help with low mood and anxiety?
Exercise demonstrably helps with low mood and anxiety, with walking, jogging and yoga as the best-studied forms. The evidence is promising, though it is not equally strong in every case.
Can you exercise too much?
Yes, exercising too much can lead to sustained loss of performance, mood problems and physical harm. The most concrete signal is a drop in performance that does not recover after more than four weeks of rest.
Is taking extra vitamin C worthwhile?
Extra vitamin C offers little benefit for most people. Intensive athletes and people following a carnivore diet do have a good reason to supplement, and those who take it daily tend to have slightly milder symptoms when they catch a cold.
Does vitamin C actually help against a cold?
Taking vitamin C daily does not protect most people against colds, but does make a cold somewhat shorter and milder. Intensive athletes benefit more. Anyone who really wants an effect during a cold would do better to look at zinc.