What does caffeine do to your stress hormones when you drink a lot of it?
High caffeine intake raises your cortisol, especially during stress or exercise and later in the day; you partially adapt to it, but the effect never disappears entirely.
Caffeine clearly raises cortisol (the main stress hormone), but how strong that effect is depends on how accustomed your body is to it. In people who had temporarily stopped consuming caffeine, a single dose caused a substantial rise in cortisol across the entire day. This effect was demonstrated in a double-blind, randomised study with 96 participants.
If you drink 300 to 600 mg of caffeine daily (roughly three to six cups of coffee), your body partially adapts. The cortisol spike after your morning coffee then disappears. But take note: only partially. After a second cup in the afternoon, cortisol still rises. So you do not build up full tolerance.
Caffeine and stress stack on top of each other. When you combine caffeine with mental pressure or physical exercise, cortisol rises more than with stress or exercise alone. Activation of the sympathetic nervous system (your fight-or-flight system) is also higher after caffeine during a stressful task than without caffeine. Men and women respond slightly differently: women show a greater cortisol rise after exercise combined with caffeine than men do, but in both sexes caffeine substantially raises cortisol over the course of the day.
People who habitually consume large amounts of caffeine respond to social stress in the laboratory with a larger cortisol peak than people who barely drink it. This is striking, because it relates to a habitual pattern over a longer period, not to whether or not you had coffee that particular day. A review of 38 studies also shows that caffeine tends to amplify the stress response rather than dampen it, comparable to nicotine but opposite to sedatives.
Finally, a note on pregnancy: there are indications that caffeine may weaken the protective barrier in the placenta, exposing the foetus to too much of the mother's stress hormone. This has been linked to cardiovascular problems in the child. The evidence behind this is, however, indirect and has not yet been studied directly in humans, so firm conclusions cannot be drawn.
All claims are based on randomised crossover studies, smaller controlled studies, and two review studies (38 and multiple studies). The core findings on cortisol and tolerance come from one robust RCT (n=96). The finding on habitual use and cortisol reactivity is associative but has been replicated in two separate samples.