longevitywatch
Research · Skin

Popular longevity supplements: which claims hold up, and which don't

LongevityWatch editors · November 19, 2026 · 4 min

From NMN to colostrum and from shilajit to antioxidants: the supplement industry bombards you with promises of a longer, healthier life. Some claims have a kernel of truth, others run well ahead of the evidence, and a handful of combinations are outright dangerous.

The supplement industry loves to sell you the idea that a handful of capsules a day slows ageing, boosts energy and keeps your memory sharp. Sometimes there is something to it, more often there isn't, and sometimes the combination is downright risky. On this page about Interventions & treatments we weigh the ten most popular claims against what the research actually says.

NMN and NR do raise your NAD+ levels – but whether you notice the difference is another matter

It is true that NMN and NR raise NAD+ levels in the blood. That is the core of the promise, and on that biochemical point the supplements deliver. But do higher NAD+ levels translate into greater muscle strength, a sharper memory or a healthier heart? That has not yet been shown in humans. The human studies are too small and the results too inconsistent for firm conclusions. The most positive findings come from animal and laboratory research, and those do not reliably translate to people. Serious side effects have not been found at the doses tested, but a proven clinical benefit has not been found either. Want to know more about what is known regarding interactions? Read about which substances are best avoided alongside NAD+, because the combination with platinum-based chemotherapy deserves serious attention.

Antioxidants only work for specific conditions

The broad promise – that antioxidant supplements slow ageing and protect your cells – runs well ahead of what the evidence shows. There are no antioxidant supplements with broadly and robustly proven health benefits. Curcumin (preferably combined with piperine) and the combination of vitamins C and E for endometriosis have the strongest signals, but these are preliminary results from small studies. If you are thinking about trying curcumin or other antioxidants as a general longevity aid, you should know that the evidence for that broad application is not there. The compound may have value for specific conditions; as a preventive anti-ageing measure for everyone, it is not supported.

Colostrum: reasonable signals for athletes, little for everyone else

Colostrum has been marketed in recent years as a broad-spectrum supplement for recovery, gut health and general vitality. That wide-ranging claim does not hold up. The most consistent positive signals concern respiratory infections in athletes who train intensively. For digestive complaints the signals are weak and studies contradict one another. For muscle strength, bone density or slowing ageing there is simply too little good research. Colostrum as a sports supplement is the most defensible application; for the rest of the claims, the evidence is absent.

Shilajit: little evidence, real safety risk

Shilajit is presented as an ancient adaptogen that boosts energy, supports hormonal balance and aids recovery. The reality is more sobering. Multiple small studies with inconsistent results show no effect convincingly enough to recommend it. On top of that, shilajit has no approved novel food status in the EU, which means it cannot legally be sold as a supplement. Unregulated products can contain heavy metals, including lead, arsenic and mercury. The risk-benefit picture for shilajit is currently negative: little to gain, a concrete risk of contamination.

Collagen works – but the type and dose determine everything

The collagen hype is partly justified. For skin, low-molecular-weight collagen peptides have the strongest backing; for knee complaints, UC-II (type II, undenatured, 40 mg per day) has the most documented clinical results, though the only independent study was negative. For bone density, hydrolysed peptides at 5 grams per day are the most studied, with positive but limited outcomes. One important caveat: a large share of the positive evidence has been funded by industry. Read more about which type of collagen best suits your goal in the full overview.

Electrolytes: unnecessary for healthy people

Electrolyte supplements have clear value in specific situations: acute diarrhoea with dehydration, premature birth and advanced kidney disease. For healthy adults who eat and exercise normally, the available studies provide no support for regular use. The marketing claim that everyone needs extra electrolytes goes further than what the research shows. If you train hard and sweat a lot, you get enough electrolytes from ordinary food and drink.

Ergothioneine: a cautiously positive signal, but too early to say

Ergothioneine, the compound found naturally in mushrooms, is attracting attention as a potential longevity supplement because of its role as a cellular antioxidant. There is one small pilot study with 19 older adults experiencing mild memory complaints that shows a positive signal. Animal research is more promising, but has not yet translated to humans. The supplement appears to be safe. Eating mushrooms is a risk-free way to get the compound; a paid supplement is worth considering only once larger studies provide more clarity.

Stacking supplements is a risk

Many people combine multiple supplements, sometimes alongside prescription drugs. Whether that is wise or dangerous depends on what you combine. St John's wort and goldenseal cause demonstrable interactions with a range of medications. A large supplement stack increases the chance of interactions, even when each individual product seems harmless on its own. If you use blood thinners such as warfarin, ginkgo biloba, cranberry and St John's wort all deserve extra attention: the first two increase the risk of bleeding, while St John's wort actually reduces the effectiveness of warfarin. Always tell your doctor or pharmacist what supplements you take, and limit your stack to products with a clear, specific reason behind them.

What does the evidence say?
Do collagen supplements work against skin ageing?
Related research
17 Nov
Cell recycling breaks down in ageing human skin cells
09 Nov
Skin cells migrate through confined spaces by switching identity in the lab
24 Oct
Topical urolithin A improves mitochondria in aging skin
Newsletter

Stay in the loop

Every Thursday, the most important longevity research in your inbox, focused on what you follow.